Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)

[Vipsoccermaster]

For the time being, Yoshiman222 has left for vacation now.

Total Votes:
No Vote: 9
Sashe: 2 (Slacker, Billy12510)

 

[Timmy]

I would like to know, does anyone else have anything to say about my role? As in, are there any objections and think I may be lying about it? If so, then why?

Or, any ideas/comments about using my role to test who's mafia/innocent (somehow )?

Spoiler: In spoilers cause it's pretty quote heavy.

Anyways, I'm looking at the story and I saw this, maybe it can help?

Some of the Yoshi's were so drowzy that he even thought it was a lion at one point, freaking out over it (not going to say who... hint).

By any chance, was it H-J because of this?

*zzz*

...

*zzz*

Maybe H-J has something hindering him in his bag that made him seem "out of it" during last night?



Onto Matt's suspicions...

I'm fairly suspicious about Voodu. He pretty much took my speculation on Slacker and reworded it after giving me s*** for it. It just seems like he's in a perfect position where you'd never think it's him.

I'm not exactly understanding this, nor your points in your argument with Voodu.

I'm still suspicious about Sashe. He and Aegis have a debate and Aegis is gone the next day. I had a FoS on him yesterday and I don't have any reason to retract it.

I can kind of agree with this, because like I said earlier, it's possible he could've OMGUS killed Aegis.

GMan. The vote took way too long. He wasn't active between day 2 and day 3 and his only post during the inbetween was half and hour before Yoshiman updated the game.

I can agree on his inactivity, but the Goomba thing makes me think he's more likely to be an innocent.



[Now to look at story details again]

Some started to notice an odd magical-bolt rolling along the ground. No one knows who might have cast it, but they knew any kind of stuff like this meant trouble for sure.

So I'm pretty sure the villain is Kamek/Magikoopa (though that should've been obvious).

...the daytime is too busy with everyone debating on who's bag they should open for you to wander off like that. Maybe when things have settled down a bit you can take a look at your surroundings...

So... Maybe during the night, we can try actions to "search" for hints about Kamek/Magikoopa (like the hat or wand) or something?

Also, looking at these...

I had a dream, and there were everyone's bags with their names on it, but not mine. I decided to check Gman's bag, and there was a Goomba in there. It tried to hurt me but was stopped by something. That goomba is a defect and it's trying to trick others into thinking that they have Baby Mario. Which means Gman is Mafia.

About the dream. It was identical to NFan's. I drifted off to sleep and everyone's bags (excluding my own) were laid before me and I got to open one of them. When I did, a Goomba jumped out and a Power Star saved me. The purpose of the Goomba was to make the owner believe that they could possibly have Baby Mario; more importantly, the description of the Goomba strongly hinted that its owner was innocent although it was never confirmed.

Why the hell would the Goomba attack them? And if the Power Star wasn't there to stop the Goomba, would Slacker & NFan would've been killed/hindered? o.o (Strongly doubting the former cause that's kind of a ridiculous penalty though lol)
I think whoever has the Power Star is meant to be a Bulletproof, or a Doctor of some sort, or stops these items from hurting someone (as in nullifying negative effects)?

NFan, were you told that a Power Star saved you from the Goomba? And also, you haven't said anything at all today, what are your thoughts on this situation?

Timmy, what are your reads on Matt/VooDu/Sashe/Gman (and everyone else, I guess)?

I'm unsure about Matt (but I guess it's cause I'm not exactly understanding some of his points/arguments ), Voodu seems innocent and has been bringing up interesting points, Sashe I'm kind of iffy about, and Gman I think he's innocent cause of the Goomba thing, though I'd like him to speak more.

Everyone else I think is pretty much innocent, but I'm unsure about Richard-o about the whole suicide thing, along with Spong (minus the suicide thing) and I'd like NFan to get in here.

Just to go back on the point of Nintendofan, did we establish that he opened Gman's back and it contained a Goomba?

NFan can open a Yoshi's back? Damn, sounds like intense surgery. o.o
(Oh the struggles of autocorrect... xD)



I'll abstain from voting for now though cause of my role, and if Prince is no longer in, I'll vote him.
However, if not him, then I'll be voting Sashe.

 

[Troll]

You mustn't of read my post right. It was supposed to be constructed like this...

after giving me s*** for it

You pointed out that the killer wasn't following anyone's answers, meaning you should've been able to answer the questions without being framed unless mafia changed their patterns.

That was the s*** I gave you for it.

He pretty much took my speculation on Slacker and reworded it

Your FoS on Slacker was about how he asked questions and then waited to answer those questions. My FoS on Slacker was about how the questions were causing so much chaos that Slacker's random vote on Sashe went under the wayside. They were completely different points

This was answering you're supposed rewording accusation. It's odd how you left the second paragraph out and took my post out of context. What happened to the second paragraph in your quoting? What's also interesting to note is that I never FoS'd Slacker, I just bought up this point I found peculiar. True, I did answer one of Prince's questions saying I'd vote Prince or Slacker if forced, but that was only because they were the only ones (to my mind) with anything suspicious on them. No way was I going to put a actually put a vote on either of them.

good thing my reply was to your whole post! who knows where the mysterious disappearing text went?!?

 

[Billy12510]

A safe vote huh? Safe for who... I know we HAVE to lynch someone today, but lynching Unknown isn't the answer. For what do we gain by lynching an innocent person? Nothing, unless you're the mafia, in which case Unknown IS a "safe vote" indeed.

FoS: TSL

Forgive me, it's just that your statement rubs me the wrong way.

 

[kinetic563]

*raises from dead* Okay... I've been spectating. Shoot me.

I can't keep quiet after I have some things I want to say... Not much, but whatever.

First of all, if Slacker's theory of there being two mafias is true... And one of them can investigate someones bag...

Why did NFan & Slacker have a dream about opening someones bag & not willingly look into someones bag? Assuming that's what happened. It is a dream, after all. Maybe no one else thought of it, but do you maybe think this puts NFan & Slacker as...possible townies...? I still feel NFan is more innocent than scum. Not to mention, where the hell is NFan?

--

On TSL's part, I find putting a safe vote on me wasn't a keen choice. When you asked all who received a PM or not I replied with:

Also, if you want MY honest opinion on whether or not I've received a PM...that answer would be no.

I'm aware that SOMEONE received some sort of role PM while others were left in the dark.

Is there anyone here who thinks I could be lying? I'll tell you right now, I'm trying to be a victor for the towns side. I'm trying to help them. And if I must say it again, I HAVE NOT RECEIVED A PM OF ANY SORT FROM THE GAMEMOD. If Mafia were given a role PM off the bat, and I'm trying to claim I haven't, why the want for a "safe vote"?

Also, the whole reason I tried going for Aegis was just the evidence I could gather & share(but maybe there was some foul play on my end in trying to rally people up). Now, my darling was clearly a good person at heart. And for that, I am sorry, my love.

I've given my reasoning for suspecting TSL. Therefore, FoS: TSL.

--

Unless I am needed for urgency...I am going back into my decaying den. *does so*

 

[H-J Kaabii]

Haha, the joys of autocorrect. I meant backpack.

Okay, there's a lot to talk about now. Time to go through everything as best I can with the iPad.

@Timmy:

The best way to confirm or deny your power is for two L-2 vote people, and then for you to vote completely differently to people who voted with you on day 1. That does kind of rely on everyone working together to vote against their hunches (possibly) though.

I was just really tired after Day 2 got nowhere, hence why I slept it off.

We'll need to investigate the Goombas.

Re Matt: I feel that part of the issue with his confusion is that he's been a bit distant from conversation in general and is now starting to make serious analysis. VooDu plays quite objectively (or distanced), I wouldn't hold meta against him just yet.

@Billy/Richard: the only reason I called it a safe vote was because it didn't look like Richard was going to respond. Now that he has, there's no reason for me to consider it a safe vote anymore. Also, while this probably works against me more than anything, why did so few people (apart from Sashe and Spong) follow through with my reasoning? Is it because Sashe is a more obvious vote choice?

@Richard specifically:

I don't quite follow the logic about how both Slacker and Nintendofan dreaming about bag checking means they are both more likely innocent, if we're using Slacker's theory.
An interesting thought which again probably makes me look scummier, but if what I said about 'I'm satisfied with Sashe's position' appears as a defense, would you be inclined to believe we are mafia partners? Remember that Sashe has denied having performed a night action. I will say it now that I haven't had any PMs during night phases.

Elaborate on what you mean that 'I'm aware that SOMEONE received some sort of role PM'. Do you mean the mafia's pm, or others? If the latter, how did you come to that information (querying a contradiction).



Spong why do you feel Richard is a better vote than Sashe? Don't wagon because you're lost. Try to come up with your own logic as to why you want to choose Richard, for example.

 

[Spongyoshi]

Well,i've been suspecting him since Day 2 
He loves telling stuff to do to others people and he is trying to catch attention!
And taking the attention is also a good way to not get suspect
Also,it seems to works (even to me) because mostly,im for his choice. But sometimes,it's a bit weird reasonings..
But i don't have A LOT of reasons anyway so im not going to vote for you for now,im still thinking carefully,im not totally sure your a mafia,you doesn't seems so guilty anyway! 

 

[H-J Kaabii]

I interpret 'you' to refer to Richard, or me?

 

[Spongyoshi]

To Richard sorry!  :mute:

 

[NintendoFan]

So, er, after my slight absence, I have read all of the posts that I missed(sigh) and I probably forgot most of them. If you had a question for me, please bring it up again.

Also, I can't really suspect anyone in my state because idk who is suspicious now.

 

[NintendoFan]

Also, I did not get a PM regarding another dream from the Gamemod during the second night phase, but that's probably because YM's away now.

 

[Guy Shy]

I HAVE NOT RECEIVED A PM OF ANY SORT FROM THE GAMEMOD.

Have you received a PM from anyone besides the gamemod? You make it seem like you've been given a PM, but from someone else. Perhaps mafia or someone with an anon message role.

good thing my reply was to your whole post! who knows where the mysterious disappearing text went?!?

I don't know how to respond to this.

 

[NintendoFan]

Vote no lynch for the time being.

 

[Troll]

Vote no lynch

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W0SHa6FuCeI

 

[Sashe2705]

• No Lynches are banned this day - I do not want there to be 3 of these happening in a row.

Vote no lynch for the time being.

You can't vote No Lynch now, NFan.

 

[NintendoFan]

• No Lynches are banned this day - I do not want there to be 3 of these happening in a row.

Vote no lynch for the time being.

You can't vote No Lynch now, NFan.

Oh, my mistake. I did read that post, but there were so many I missed that I forgot about half what I read.

Anyway, yeah, i'll remove that vote.

 

[Troll]

• No Lynches are banned this day - I do not want there to be 3 of these happening in a row.

Vote no lynch for the time being.

You can't vote No Lynch now, NFan.

Oh, my mistake. I did read that post, but there were so many I missed that I forgot about half what I read.

usually it's a good idea to take note of what's in the post that the gamemaster writes.

 

[NintendoFan]

Anyway... What do we do now? I really don't know who should I vote; if I should vote at all in this state.

 

[Slacker]

Why did NFan & Slacker have a dream about opening someones bag & not willingly look into someones bag? Assuming that's what happened. It is a dream, after all. Maybe no one else thought of it, but do you maybe think this puts NFan & Slacker as...possible townies...? I still feel NFan is more innocent than scum. Not to mention, where the hell is NFan?

I want to clarify this real quick, although I might be misinterpreting your post. I did willingly choose to look into someone's bag; however, I do not want to reveal their name (yet) and give mafia an advantage.


As for the votes, we're running out of time. I don't think anyone has any good leads and I hardly doubt that we will find enough "evidence" to put together even a slightly plausible vote. I say we just vote whoever we think is most suspicious. If we don't come close to a consensus (which I doubt we will at this pace) then Yoshiman will just randomly lynch someone anyway.


Remove my vote on Sashe. I'm not entirely convinced of Sashe's innocence, but he is not the most deserving of a vote this day phase. I still feel suspicious of Billy and Gman, although I have no proof on either of them and no real reason to think so.

 

[Vipsoccermaster]

NintendoFan, I've had quite enough of your presence around this game. I'm sorry, but you're done here. You will be replaced, effectively NOW. I'm also going to remove your vote, even though you opted to remove your vote earlier, it was not bolded.

I'm looking for a replacement, anyone that could, please do so?

Total Votes:
No Vote: 10
Sashe: 1 (Billy12510)

With 11 members, it still takes 6 to lynch, and a No Lynch are banned this day.