Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)

Slacker said:
I'm on the fence with Sashe right now. It's not just the bandwagoning that has been going on with him, but I feel as though most of his posts have just been copycats of others. Sashe I want you to give me a fresh perspective on our situation.
Vote: Sashe (I'll remove if your response is satisfactory.)
Click to expand...

I'll explain. Sure, I may've raised some suspicion but don't you remember that VooDu asked me the same thing on Day 2 and I told him to look at my last Mafia game. I hope you've saw it, too. However, you want to hear my opinion. As I said before, I don't have enough evidence to vote for someone but the only person I suspect at the moment is you, Slacker. H-J suspected me because I was bandwagoning and "following the pack". VooDu did it, too. They didn't vote for me, though, because the evidence isn't enough. And now, suddenly, you decide to vote for me. Why? Do you have more evidence against me or you have only that? Because if you don't have, well, then it'll be very suspicious.

FoS Slacker. I'd like to hear if you have more evidence against me. Also, I want to know what did you got in your PM, too.
 
Slacker said:
Gamemod, one question about your story. You said the Goomba ran into the wall and we thought nothing of it. Is there a way to investigate the Goomba or anything we can do with it?
Click to expand...
On this note I would just like to say something no one has done this game yet.
Nighttime

...the daytime is too busy with everyone debating on who's bag they should open for you to wander off like that. Maybe when things have settled down a bit you can take a look at your surroundings...Total Votes :
No Vote : 10
Sashe : 1 (Slacker)
 
Yoshiman222 said:
daytime is too busy with everyone debating on who's bag they should open for you to wander off like that. Maybe when things have settled down a bit you can take a look at your surroundings...
Click to expand...
Oh you  :-D

About the dream. It was identical to NFan's. I drifted off to sleep and everyone's bags (excluding my own) were laid before me and I got to open one of them. When I did, a Goomba jumped out and a Power Star saved me. The purpose of the Goomba was to make the owner believe that they could possibly have Baby Mario; more importantly, the description of the Goomba strongly hinted that its owner was innocent although it was never confirmed.

About you. I do remember when VooDu asked you about the bandwagoning, and I followed up with him for clarification on that. I wasn't talking about just the bandwagoning (as I said), I was commenting on how the majority of your posts were copies of others' posts/following their logic.

Focusing on your votes:
Sashe2705 said:
I suspect NFan cause he didn't want to answer Slacker's questions. That's why I'll Vote: NintendoFan for now. I will withdraw my vote if he give me an explanation why he didn't want to answer the questions.
Click to expand...
This follows Aegis's and KB's votes/reasoning. In addition to this, I'd say you voted on NFan with less evidence than I voted on you.

Sashe2705 said:
So, Matt explained why he didn't want to answer the questions. Sure, Slacker is a little suspicious because he asked these questions, but I still doubt that he's Mafia. And although the Mafia player may really want to put Aegis and NFan on the hot seat, I agree with Unknown that he's been acting a bit silly and is quite suspicious. Also, I think that he's too quiet (just like a Mafia player would do). I think that evidence is enough for me to Vote: Aegis.
Click to expand...
This follows Kinetic's vote/reasoning.

Focusing on your conversation with Aegis:
Sashe2705 said:
Aegis said:
I am just gonna Vote: Sashe because of his crap reasonings for people potentially being Mafia.
Click to expand...

Many people have voted without any hard proof. I doubt that I'm the only one who doesn't have any hard proof for people being Mafia. Like your vote against NFan on Day 1...
Click to expand...
Like your vote against NFan on Day 1 as well.

Sashe2705 said:
Aegis said:
I am just gonna Vote: Sashe because of his crap reasonings for people potentially being Mafia.
Click to expand...

Also, how did you suddenly forgot about your suspicion of Unknown and decided to vote for me instead?
Click to expand...
You dropped your vote against Aegis and turned on Unknown quickly, who you had just sided with.

Generally suspicious comments:
Sashe2705 said:
The Shattered Legacy said:
This is the second time you've wagoned... Hmm. I'll keep an eye on you.

FoS Sashe
Click to expand...

Do you really think that wagoning is suspicious if you have good reasons for voting a person?
Click to expand...
Sashe2705 said:
I mean, I've changed my opinion. I may be "following the pack" but that's because I don't want to risk to raise suspicion on me if I vote first.
Click to expand...

I can get more quotes, but this is exhausting going through all of the posts. You said that the evidence isn't "enough" to place a vote on you, but what exactly is enough in a game supposedly without a cop/doctor/major power role? The main reason I threw a vote on you again was to see how your reaction changed from my initial random vote on you early in the game. This time around you are much jumpier, almost to the point of a OMGUS vote when you're still five votes away from a lynch. Your use of metagame as a justification to jump on and vote other people out quickly is a big excuse. It would be an obvious tactic but does not sit well with me nonetheless and can easily be distorted by mafia even if you aren't sided with them. I don't know if FoSing me was the fresh perspective I asked for, but you already did that earlier in the game right after Matt said I was suspicious.

I think you're over-reacting a bit to my vote. We're on a force lynch and votes are the quickest way to see someone's thoughts. I'm keeping my vote on you for the time being.
 
MattC said:
I'm fairly suspicious about Voodu. He pretty much took my speculation on Slacker and reworded it after giving me s*** for it. It just seems like he's in a perfect position where you'd never think it's him.
Click to expand...
That isn't really what I said. You pointed out that the killer wasn't following anyone's answers, meaning you should've been able to answer the questions without being framed unless mafia changed their patterns.

Your FoS on Slacker was about how he asked questions and then waited to answer those questions. My FoS on Slacker was about how the questions were causing so much chaos that Slacker's random vote on Sashe went under the wayside. They were completely different points
 
Also, what is the official status of Richard? If he's purposely pretending to be dead out of his own unrequited devotion, then what's stopping us from voting him out as a 'safe' vote?

I don't really want to do that, but I suppose we will have to hear from the man himself if he is dead or alive.
 
VooDu said:
MattC said:
I'm fairly suspicious about Voodu. He pretty much took my speculation on Slacker and reworded it after giving me s*** for it. It just seems like he's in a perfect position where you'd never think it's him.
Click to expand...
That isn't really what I said. You pointed out that the killer wasn't following anyone's answers, meaning you should've been able to answer the questions without being framed unless mafia changed their patterns.
Click to expand...
Except that wasn't the point I was trying to get across?!?!?!?!?!?!!?!?!?!!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!!?

I originally put an FoS on Slacker for asking the questions in the first place. If I hadn't said anything, you would've never suspected Slacker because no one else would've brought up the questions and there wouldn't have been a fuss about it.
 
Good lord my computer is slow, sorry if I missed anyone's post.
I think we should allow Sashe a chance to defend himself before throwing any more votes at him.

The Shattered Legacy said:
Slacker, did you know whose bag you opened?
Click to expand...
Yessir I did; the only stipulation was that I could not open my bag. I'm open for discussion on this topic, but I think not revealing is the best possible thing to do in this situation. The town may not get a (kinda) clear for the time being, but this information is very valuable to the mafia and keeping it out of their hands means potentially extending the game and town chances of winning.

VooDu said:
Your FoS on Slacker was about how he asked questions and then waited to answer those questions. My FoS on Slacker was about how the questions were causing so much chaos that Slacker's random vote on Sashe went under the wayside. They were completely different points
Click to expand...
Wait your argument concluded with me trying to get Sashe out on the first day by using the questions as a diversion? I completely misunderstood the first time you brought this up. I think that this is a tad far fetched.

Regardless, how do you feel about me voting Sashe now?

While I'm at it: Billy what are your thoughts on the game so far? Sorry for how generic this question sounds haha but I want to hear from you.
 
You mustn't of read my post right. It was supposed to be constructed like this...
MattC said:
after giving me s*** for it
Click to expand...
VooDu said:
You pointed out that the killer wasn't following anyone's answers, meaning you should've been able to answer the questions without being framed unless mafia changed their patterns.
Click to expand...
That was the s*** I gave you for it.

VooDu said:
MattC said:
He pretty much took my speculation on Slacker and reworded it
Click to expand...
Your FoS on Slacker was about how he asked questions and then waited to answer those questions. My FoS on Slacker was about how the questions were causing so much chaos that Slacker's random vote on Sashe went under the wayside. They were completely different points
Click to expand...
This was answering you're supposed rewording accusation. It's odd how you left the second paragraph out and took my post out of context. What happened to the second paragraph in your quoting? What's also interesting to note is that I never FoS'd Slacker, I just bought up this point I found peculiar. True, I did answer one of Prince's questions saying I'd vote Prince or Slacker if forced, but that was only because they were the only ones (to my mind) with anything suspicious on them. No way was I going to put a actually put a vote on either of them.

Slacker said:
VooDu said:
Your FoS on Slacker was about how he asked questions and then waited to answer those questions. My FoS on Slacker was about how the questions were causing so much chaos that Slacker's random vote on Sashe went under the wayside. They were completely different points
Click to expand...
Wait your argument concluded with me trying to get Sashe out on the first day by using the questions as a diversion? I completely misunderstood the first time you brought this up. I think that this is a tad far fetched.
Click to expand...
My argument was about how the questions created chaos and your random vote on Sashe never came up in conversation. Doesn't that seem odd? Yes it is far-fetched, and that why I didn't even FoS you.

Your vote on Sashe now is fine as you bought up evidence against him unlike last time were you random voted him.
 
Slacker said:
I think we should allow Sashe a chance to defend himself before throwing any more votes at him.
Click to expand...

Thank you. Now, I know that I over-reacted a bit to your vote, but I suspected you because many people suspected me due to my bandwagoning, but none of them turned it into a vote. Sure, I know we're in a "Must Lynch" situation. You voted me on Day 1 to see how will I react. Nothing special here. You vote me again with all the evidence you have, plus, to see how will I react again. I'm "jumpier" now, because it was just a random vote on Day 1. Random votes against you aren't something that you should be afraid of. However, now you are voting me again, but it's not randomly this time.

Now, I'll explain my votes. First, the vote against NFan on Day 1. Why do you think that I followed KB and Aegis' reasoning with that vote? KB's vote was because "He's an idiot.", which is something like a random vote. Aegis' vote wasn't different, too. It was kinda random again. I voted him because he didn't want to answer your last question. If I remember, you suspected Matt on Day 2 for the same reason. Sure, I didn't have much evidence against him but I think that it's better to vote someone with all the evidence you have, rather than voting randomly.

Next is my vote against Aegis. Here, I agree with you that I followed Unknown's reasoning. I was suspecting him because of all the silly stuff he did on Night 1 and because he was way too quiet.

My conversation with Aegis. My vote on NFan on Day 1 wasn't because of hard proof, but at least I had something. Aegis' vote was completely random.

Next, I turned on Unknown because when H-J suspected me due to bandwagoning, he was kinda defending me. Me, the only person who voted Aegis except for him. The Mafia player has to make the town lynch the person with Baby Mario and I thought that he knew that Aegis had Baby Mario.

And finally, the "suspicious comments". I was trying to defend myself when H-J suspected me. And the other one, I told you to look at my last Mafia game to understand what I mean.

Well, that's my explanation.
 
I'll need a bit of time to read over VooDu and Matt's comments. I'm satisfied right now with Sashe's position, but if I could ask, who would you vote now based on your obese rations and judgement?

Timmy, what are your reads on Matt/VooDu/Sashe/Gman (and everyone else, I guess)?

Just to go back on the point of Nintendofan, did we establish that he opened Gman's back and it contained a Goomba?
 
The Shattered Legacy said:
I'm satisfied right now with Sashe's position, but if I could ask, who would you vote now based on your obese rations and judgement?
Click to expand...

Probably the person who's been acting kinda strange all the time - Richard. As I said, he defended me when you suspected me and I was the only person beside him who voted for Aegis. He may've thought that Aegis has Baby Mario because he had a Goomba in his bag. I'm still thinking that he was trying to make people vote for Aegis. And all that suicide thing seems a bit suspicious to me... :p. I don't know if he's actually dead or not, though.
 
Today on "Mafia Book Club!"

Billy12510 recommends: "Yoshi's Island Mafia 2: Revenge of the Koopas!" By Yoshiman & Jinx.

'A tale of mystery and intrigue as a group of Shy Guys bands together to save their village of Saffore from the Yoshi invaders!'

Just hear what people had to say about it: 'I laughed!' 'I cried!' 'I lost 15 pounds somehow!' 'I can't begin recommending this book to others enough.'

"Yoshi's Island Mafia 2: Revenge of the Koopas!" Buy it today!


.... But in all seriousness I bring this up because I did take your advice Sashe and read through this again. (Pretty good read as well.) If I recall correctly you did a lot of voting with a lack of evidence. But you had hard suspicions (Which isn't a bad thing, for what is faith without doubt?) I feel like we are being a BIT hard on you... but you weren't earning any points with your behavior.

As for my opinion on how the game's progressed... I felt like we WERE making progress... but after a few of us started coming to the realization that Aegis was innocent we seemed to hit a funk that we never got out of yesterday. (Aegis and Unknown's "voting" didn't help much.)

I'm just going to say this: Unknown what the fuck? Don't do this to us man, we love you.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top