How about we let Yoshiman run the game as he wants to and critique it afterwards?
Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)
- Thread starter Yoshiman222
- Start date
Isn't everybody talking about the game is a part of the game? :mute:
To answer Slacker's questions...
1. I guess I'd be considered a bit of a mafia veteran. At least I'd consider myself to be one.
2. That's something that would depend on the mafia's actions.
3. Hmm... it could very depending on the person. Speaking from experience a mafia members tendencies tend to lean towards blending in with a crowd and silently killing off the people in said crowd.
4. Someone with a lot of experience, like myself or you Slacker.
1. I guess I'd be considered a bit of a mafia veteran. At least I'd consider myself to be one.
2. That's something that would depend on the mafia's actions.
3. Hmm... it could very depending on the person. Speaking from experience a mafia members tendencies tend to lean towards blending in with a crowd and silently killing off the people in said crowd.
4. Someone with a lot of experience, like myself or you Slacker.
1. Not exactly the best player, but not bad either.
2. Probably not, he's outnumbered by 12 others.
3. I think he would act like everyone else. It depends on how experienced said player is.
4. I don't want to answer that.
2. Probably not, he's outnumbered by 12 others.
3. I think he would act like everyone else. It depends on how experienced said player is.
4. I don't want to answer that.
Re Slacker's questions
1. I have enough experience but I wouldn't call myself a hardened vet
2. Depends on how well they know to garner trust from the town; otherwise it probably is about the same as a normal game
3. As per 2, try to get on everyone's good side, eliminate those who make themselves suspicious, and then go for the decisive kill. Alternatively they could play passively and seem inconspicuous.
4. Slacker for rallying everyone right off the bat. Unknown because of his potential to reveal the truth or at least make powerful deductions at an opportune moment. KB for making himself appear suspicious thus far. And maybe Spong for seeming a bit enthusiastic which might draw the wrong kind of attention to him.
...and me for being me.
NintendoFan, you are the only one who hasn't offered an answer to the fourth question - care to explain why?
1. I have enough experience but I wouldn't call myself a hardened vet
2. Depends on how well they know to garner trust from the town; otherwise it probably is about the same as a normal game
3. As per 2, try to get on everyone's good side, eliminate those who make themselves suspicious, and then go for the decisive kill. Alternatively they could play passively and seem inconspicuous.
4. Slacker for rallying everyone right off the bat. Unknown because of his potential to reveal the truth or at least make powerful deductions at an opportune moment. KB for making himself appear suspicious thus far. And maybe Spong for seeming a bit enthusiastic which might draw the wrong kind of attention to him.
...and me for being me.
NintendoFan, you are the only one who hasn't offered an answer to the fourth question - care to explain why?
The Shattered Legacy said:
I'm not very comfortable picking who I want dead(Yes, I know I have a story where I do that, but this is different). I have no reason to kill any of you.
Also,
Slacker said:
So,what should we do? Do you think we should lynchee someone or just wait for now? :-\
I'm not sure where we go from here...
There are no telltale signs of anyone putting on suspicion.
If no one is eager enough to question others, IDK.
Do we just move on with this day & hope that we are all mistaken?
Or do we TRY to get info on who the bad guy is?
There are no telltale signs of anyone putting on suspicion.
If no one is eager enough to question others, IDK.
Do we just move on with this day & hope that we are all mistaken?
Or do we TRY to get info on who the bad guy is?
The chances of handing the win to the mafia increase with each day phase assuming we get picked off in the nights
But there's really no lead and I don't know what any of us can do with our bags...
Ugh...
We need more talk first I think.
But there's really no lead and I don't know what any of us can do with our bags...
Ugh...
We need more talk first I think.
There are quite a number of people who've yet to show themselves too...
I'd like to hear what they have to say thus far...
I'd like to hear what they have to say thus far...
I still vote not to lynch. No reason to kill people off on the first day because of speculation.
Well,i will go to sleep... See you tomorrow and i guess i will see how gets killed when im back!
Hope it's not me,haha :-D
Hope it's not me,haha :-D
Quoting myself ftwSlacker said:
1. I've hosted a heavy share of mafia on this forum, played in like two on here I think. I've played in a few on other forums.
2. I would say that it'd probably be easier in this game to hide because it'll mostly rely on guesswork and trying to put together a solid case against someone with nothing.
3. Ideally, kingboo's actions of going after NFan (but looks more like a jester). Realistically, staying quiet and jumping on a bandwagon if necessary, otherwise fighting it so they can look innocent.
4. HJ is always the first to go in everything. He is good with analysis and knows a lot of the player's styles.
Spong doesn't seem all that guilty to me. KB doesn't seem all that guilty to me unless he's pulling some reverse psychology. I like Kinetic's idea of hearing from everyone before deciding on anything.
Random Vote: Sashe for now.
Sorry if it seemed like I was critiquing Yoshiman's game, I'm not.
I haven't been N1 killed in a while recently which I find pretty odd
/inb4 I'm dead
/inb4 I'm dead
I swear I remember Yoshiman saying their might not be night phases.
@Slackers questions
1. Not much, I've played a couple mafias but I haven't play this style of mafia before
2. No
3. Probably act like a good guy but really be evil on the inside.
4. Like Slacker said, probably HJ cause he has pretty good deduction skills. I'd also say Slacker cause he's hosted some mafias and I reckon that'd give him the upper hand in figuring out people's techniques.
To Sashe, how do you feel about Slacker random lynching you and do you think that casts suspicion on him.
To KB, was there any reasoning behind your vote to NintendoFan
@Slackers questions
1. Not much, I've played a couple mafias but I haven't play this style of mafia before
2. No
3. Probably act like a good guy but really be evil on the inside.
4. Like Slacker said, probably HJ cause he has pretty good deduction skills. I'd also say Slacker cause he's hosted some mafias and I reckon that'd give him the upper hand in figuring out people's techniques.
To Sashe, how do you feel about Slacker random lynching you and do you think that casts suspicion on him.
To KB, was there any reasoning behind your vote to NintendoFan
I refuse to answer any questions without consulting my attorney.
Your... Ace Attorney?
To Slacker's questions:
1. This is my second Mafia game so I don't have much experience...
2. No
3. He'll act as an innocent and stay quiet until someone suspects him.
4. Probably Slacker, Billy or H-J because they have the most experience.
Well, I doubt that he thinks I'm suspicious. He just puts a random vote on me to keep the game going and to see how will I react. I don't think kingboo suspects NFan either.
1. This is my second Mafia game so I don't have much experience...
2. No
3. He'll act as an innocent and stay quiet until someone suspects him.
4. Probably Slacker, Billy or H-J because they have the most experience.
VooDu said:
Well, I doubt that he thinks I'm suspicious. He just puts a random vote on me to keep the game going and to see how will I react. I don't think kingboo suspects NFan either.
I'm gonna vote NintendoFan as well.
*sigh*
We really aren't getting anywhere.
Well. I guess I'll say if I end up dead in the night, it was nice...ummm...trying to figure the villain out while it lasted.
Still no vote here.
We really aren't getting anywhere.
Well. I guess I'll say if I end up dead in the night, it was nice...ummm...trying to figure the villain out while it lasted.
Still no vote here.