Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)

Matt ninja'd me. But yeah, that's me. The same person.

So people don't get confused...perhaps the mod should change it to "Alive - Prince Richard-o".
 
Well before we end the day here, I think it's worth saying a few words here.

Yoshiman said that the menace was the only person who received a role PM so I'm going to go ahead and assume that there are no pro-town night roles at work here. What does everyone think about the mechanics of the game? If the menace's only goal would be to lynch someone, would it make sense for him to have a night power/killing power?

Thinking ahead here because I'm not entirely sure night phases will provide clues like other games. No suspicion on kingboo, random vote is acceptable at this stage.
 
Y'know. Slacker's right, actually.

All we're doing by not trying to put suspicion on someone isn't helping anyone.

Slacker said:
Yoshiman said that the menace was the only person who received a role PM so I'm going to go ahead and assume that there are no pro-town night roles at work here. If the menace's only goal would be to lynch someone, would it make sense for him to have a night power/killing power?
Click to expand...

If that's the case the good people would certainly have a disadvantage, wouldn't some of you agree? It would ALSO make night times practically USELESS for the good of us.

We need to gather intel on the 13 of us that are here while we have the chance before nightfall.

So, in all honesty, I'd suggest we think more about this.

I withdraw my 'no lynch' and I'm going to be on a stand still.

Let's see if anyone can convince themselves they are ONE OF THE GOOD GUYS.
 
Slacker makes a good point. The only issue is... how do we prove that one is good? There's not a whole lot to go on, and just throwing out names doesn't do a whole lot. (Albeit it's better then nothing.)

withdrawing my vote Haste makes waste, and who knows who's going to survive the night? Best to try and figure things out while everyone's still alive.
 
I'd...personally...would like to see NFan's take on why Kingboo decided to put a vote out on him out of the blue.
 
Spongyoshi said:
I got the perfect answer for all of this!
Put you hand up if you are a Yoshi!
Put his hand up This can only works! ;D
Click to expand...

Oh? It could? Well, I suppose it COULD. But wouldn't everyone want to do that to save themselves from getting the boot?

Sooooo... Why did YOU want to suggest this? Perhaps you want to act out as the good guy by giving a rather appealing suggestion... But in reality...you are the one we are trying to find...
 
My guess for now is that the one mafia has the ability to kill over night but only wins if his target is lynched, basically he'd have the ability to narrow the field. Or as far as we know, I could've read too far into things and we do have pro-town roles; though I'm doubting it as of now. If anyone does have a town role, I obviously wouldn't reveal yourself right away until we see what goes during the night--role claiming could be useful later on.

As for figuring out who could be mafia, I'll start questioning random people and seeing what the general idea is. It's the only idea I have right now lol

Everyone:
How much experience do you have playing mafia?
Do you think this game would be easier for mafia to hide in as opposed to others?
What type of tendencies/behaviors do you think the menace would show?
If you were mafia and had the ability to kill overnight, who would you target first and why? (I know this question could be incriminating and understand if anyone declines.)

I will answer these myself later (I need to go) but I think this should give us a good idea of everyone? It'll have to be a pretty discussion heavy game if we want to win. Feel free to add/discuss.
 
Spongyoshi said:
Do you REALLY think that the bad guy will do theses kinds instead of acting secretly?  :mute:
Click to expand...

I assure you... You MAY be acting good on the outside to put the suspicion away from you...

That does not mean it puts you as the one... But it is something to think about...

Slacker said:
Everyone:
How much experience do you have playing mafia?
Do you think this game would be easier for mafia to hide in as opposed to others?
What type of tendencies/behaviors do you think the menace would show?
If you were mafia and had the ability to kill overnight, who would you target first and why? (I know this question could be incriminating and understand if anyone declines.)
Click to expand...

Allow me to express my opinions on this.

1. Well, I wouldn't say I am over the top. Maybe in the middle?

2. Oh. Definitely. Having an idea of night roles really helps others in figuring out who could be who. But here...we barely have ANYTHING to go by. A very tricky situation... A simple mistake could cause the whole destruction of our fellow good people...

3. My first instinct would be to try to act out as the good guy to prevent them from being suspicious. But also being silent as to watch the rest of us bickering on & on while they LAUGH THEIR A** OFF.

4. Heh. Good question. Mayhap I leave it to others to say.

MattC said:
I have no idea what's going on. ???
Click to expand...

Go back to your shelter that is paid for by a clock.
 
Slacker said:
How much experience do you have playing mafia?
Click to expand...
None.

Slacker said:
Do you think this game would be easier for mafia to hide in as opposed to others?
Click to expand...
No.

Slacker said:
What type of tendencies/behaviors do you think the menace would show?
Click to expand...
Idiocy.

Slacker said:
If you were mafia and had the ability to kill overnight, who would you target first and why?
Click to expand...
NFan.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top