Wording it in your own words it okay. It's when you quote it in my style that it's a problem. Basically, no story-telling.NintendoFan said:
That goes for all of you.
Total Votes :
No Vote : 9
Sashe : 2 (Aegis, Richard-o)
No Lynch : 1 (NFan)
Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)
- Thread starter Yoshiman222
- Start date
That goes for all of you.
Total Votes :
No Vote : 9
Sashe : 2 (Aegis, Richard-o)
No Lynch : 1 (NFan)
I'm being pressured & why I honestly don't want to answer anything. My mind is a mess... This day has just been chaotic...
Also, if you want MY honest opinion on whether or not I've received a PM...that answer would be no.
I'm aware that SOMEONE received some sort of role PM while others were left in the dark.
Also, if you want MY honest opinion on whether or not I've received a PM...that answer would be no.
I'm aware that SOMEONE received some sort of role PM while others were left in the dark.
Now we're talking.
Aegis/Nintendofan - do your PMs mention any certain person or role?
Richard - if I understand you correctly and you don't mean the pm sent to the mafia before game start, this means... You're a watcher or pseudo-interceptor? Do you know how many PMs were sent to people, or any further details?
Aegis/Nintendofan - do your PMs mention any certain person or role?
Richard - if I understand you correctly and you don't mean the pm sent to the mafia before game start, this means... You're a watcher or pseudo-interceptor? Do you know how many PMs were sent to people, or any further details?
I haven't received any PM's.
The Shattered Legacy said:
My PM didn't specifically say what role I was; but the information I had to give back pretty much told me what role I was. Right now I put whatever happened in my own words in the PM I guess?
NintendoFan said:
Wait what you had to give information to someone else? O-o
Yes sure, go ahead.
The Shattered Legacy said:
I had a dream, and there were everyone's bags with their names on it, but not mine. I decided to check Gman's bag, and there was a Goomba in there. It tried to hurt me but was stopped by something. That goomba is a defect and it's trying to trick others into thinking that they have Baby Mario. Which means Gman is Mafia.
Withdraw my no lynch vote and vote Gman.
oplzgodkillmenao
I didn't receive a PM from the mod, so I'm not sure what my role is.
NintendoFan said:
I don't see how this suggests I'm Mafia. And also, what motive would I even have for killing KB first if I were to be Mafia? The only thing he did was vote you.
So Gman's bag is trying to trick others into thinking they have Baby Mario. Does the mean multiple people would've gotten a PM saying they have Baby Mario?
It'd seem the Goomba is making it harder for the mafia (unless they actually know who has Baby Mario). I'd like to hear what NFan and Gman think of this PM and what it means for the situation.
It'd seem the Goomba is making it harder for the mafia (unless they actually know who has Baby Mario). I'd like to hear what NFan and Gman think of this PM and what it means for the situation.
VooDu said:
I personally think that this PM actually helps the Mafia. It seems to eliminate me from the " who has Baby Mario" question and makes it that much easier for the Mafia to find out who does have Baby Mario.
Whilst it does eliminate you having Baby Mario, there could be multiple of these in play, meaning more than one person could think they have Baby Mario. Doesn't sound to helpful to me but I might just be reading NFan's post wrong.
Let me clarify. The person that has this Baby Mario fake is well, trying to trick others into thinking that they have Baby Mario, and is trying to get the real Yoshi that has the real Baby Mario. Also, you do have a motive, Gman, Me and kingboo had a sort of fight on Day 1, so you killed him to cast suspicion on me. Pay attention.
I didn't get a PM.
While I don't think that NFan is really a credible source, I'm also skeptical of GMan. He's been really quiet and hasn't really had a ton of input.
While I don't think that NFan is really a credible source, I'm also skeptical of GMan. He's been really quiet and hasn't really had a ton of input.
Wait a moment.
Doesn't the mafia know who their target is from the start? That means the fake Baby Mario carrier... won't be of any use. lol
Doesn't the mafia know who their target is from the start? That means the fake Baby Mario carrier... won't be of any use. lol
*taps foot; crosses arms*
I'm still waiting for you lot to decide on your actions.
I'm still waiting for you lot to decide on your actions.
Uhhhh...The Shattered Legacy said:
I don't really understand NFan's PM. I get that he's pretty much an oracle of some sort, but the rest I'm kinda unsure of.
Gman, you seemed to defend your innocence when this was brought up, but you did not deny knowing that you had this ability. Did you know that you had the ability to make someone think they were the new target of the menace? Would keeping you alive make the menace have a more difficult time of trying to track down his target?
Makes sense, no need to check your own bag.NintendoFan said:
Goomba is typically a bad character, but KB had a leecher(?) so I can't really rule on this.NintendoFan said:
I can't tell if this is a story detail or someone with a blocking power at work, leaning toward the former.NintendoFan said:
I don't see how your first statement leads to your second statement. However, I would like more clarification on this Goomba ability if you have any other details NFan.NintendoFan said:
Gman, you seemed to defend your innocence when this was brought up, but you did not deny knowing that you had this ability. Did you know that you had the ability to make someone think they were the new target of the menace? Would keeping you alive make the menace have a more difficult time of trying to track down his target?
The Shattered Legacy said:
This troubles me a little bit based on what HJ said. You're (Gman's) quote here convinces me that you know more than you're letting on. At first I thought that you might have some sort of role where you can switch which bags the Baby Mario was in, but here you're saying that the mafia doesn't know which bag the target is in. I'm confused. I'm starting to think I misinterpreted the game. :LGmanextreme9 said:
I was under the impression that the mafia didn't know who had Baby Mario and had to try and work out who it is and get the town to lynch them. This would be pretty hard for mafia, but now that I think about it, mafia would have to know who has Baby Mario incase they kill the holder at night. Or maybe if they kill the holder at night, Baby Mario moves to a different person? Maybe they could see inside one persons bag per night kinda like a Cop role to figure out who has Baby Mario?
Damn it this is frustrating, perhaps Yoshiman could give us some more info if that's allowed?
Damn it this is frustrating, perhaps Yoshiman could give us some more info if that's allowed?
Also, Gman, it doesn't help the mafia at all because I just exposed them. The Mafia is pretending to have Baby Mario so he can kill the rest of us. If you need more clarification, then i'm stunned at how much you need. It's ridiculous.