Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)

Billy12510 said:
Damn... the bastard got Timmy.

I think the most interesting development out of all of this is this bit here...
Yoshiman222 said:
However, while the Yoshi's didn't think too much of it at first, some just couldn't help but notice how [/i]VooDu, Spongyoshi, Sashe, and Billy's bags all started to glow ominously...
Click to expand...

Why specifically the four of us? One very real possibility is that... the menace is one of the four people mentioned.

HJ, please tell me that this missing vowels thing is a timed-thing and you'll inevitably get them back. Because as it stands I'm having a REALLY hard time understanding you.
Click to expand...


So does that mean me and MattC are automatically revealed innocent?

Anyway...

Slacker said:
I say we lynch one of the four listed and everyone investigates the crystal ball next night phase. I have voiced my suspicions against three of the four I think.
Click to expand...

That's probably what we should do.
 
Tsl translations
The Shattered Legacy said:
Before, vote would like know if anyone received night dream message.
Click to expand...
None here.
The Shattered Legacy said:
Very(?) confident in Gman having Goomba
Click to expand...
Don't have anything to contribute here but I'm not sure if very is right as there was a n after very

The Shattered Legacy said:
Good point Slacker are(?) glowing bags
Click to expand...
Nothing to contribute here

The Shattered Legacy said:
Lets thinking Kamek kill
Kingboo, Aegis, Timmy - rdr fls that Kamek srs now
Click to expand...
I have no idea on some of those words.

Trying to think what could be glowing in the bags, they have to be something we haven't seen yet. Maybe a Bulb Fruit? Or if one of us is Mafia, maybe Kamek's Wand.

Billy, can you give us reasonswhy you are so much more confident Spong is Mafia
 
Actually, I think that our glowing bags mean that one of us has some kind of a special role. By the way, YMan said that "Kamek was able to defeat the others so quietly." Is this a part of the story or he is referring to someone who has been quiet all the time. Now, I don't think we should go with a "No Lynch" again. I think we should vote for someone. I don't know about the others but I suspected NFan and Spong on Day 3.

Sashe2705 said:
You're probably right, but NFan has been quiet, too. Well, the first killed was KB and then Aegis. They both were people who wanted NFan lynched. So the Mafia may know what is in NFan's bag. That makes me think... if Slacker's theory's right and there are 2 Mafia players with one of them being able to look at others' bags, it's possible that NFan and Spong are Mafia partners. NFan defended Spong several times when you suspected him. Plus, NFan already looked at GMan's bag, so it's possible that he can look at others' bags. I doubt that, though, because Slacker received a PM and he looked in another player's bag (except if he doesn't have some kind of a special role). By the way, Slacker, can you finally tell us which bag did you look in and what was in it. I don't see a reason why not to tell us, except if you know who has Baby Mario. I don't have much evidence, though, and Yoshiman said that whoever has the most votes is out, so we should be careful about who are we going to vote for. Billy, you're right that GMan has been bandwagoning, too, but I don't suspect him. However, the person that I suspect the most is still Richard.

FoS: NFan, Spong and Richard
Click to expand...

However, NFan wasn't online for a few days so I think that explains why he was quiet. Spong, however, is active but like Billy said he's been "lurking in the shadows" all the time and waiting until the others make a decision. I think that he's the most suspicious now. And if the theory that one of us is Mafia, I think it's none other than Spong.

Vote: Spongyoshi
 
Well, Spongyoshi seems to be the most suspicious right now. He has been lurking(Despite it being very late where he lives) and hasn't really said anything useful. Even though at first I defended him, i'm not so sure right now. The only reason I ever did that was because he was my friend. Guess you really can't trust anyone in Mafia unless they are 100% innocent.

Vote Spongyoshi.
 
I'd like to hear how Spong feels about all the votes against him.

FoS Spong
I agree with the idea of him "lurking in the shadows", but I've done the same thing as him numerous times, came on the forum but didn't post because I had nothing to add to the conversation. Then again, his posts are generally unhelpful, there's very few of them and majority of them are just saying I dunno who to vote for and that he's going to wait to vote.
 
Slacker said:
This bandwagoning is silly. Votes on Spong are based off of his inexperience, he's acting like a player would in his first game. I'm not sold on his innocence yet, but I think everyone who just voted him right after each other cast a shade of suspicion over themselves.
Click to expand...

So that makes Billy, Sashe, and myself suspicious? I mean, Billy's bag glowed, so does that make him even more suspicious now that he's voted Spong?

I'm not entirely convinced yet so i'll keep my vote until Spong comes back Sunday and hopefully give an explanation.
 
I have nothing useful to post anyway... And everybody seems happier anyway when im not talking so..  :mute:
Go ahead! I can't even defend myself.. The judgement has been done.
I will be lynched,you will waste a vote,one of you all will be killed by the mafia and.... i will finally see what's in my bag!  :D
I can't really try to change your ideas,and if i try too much,i will be viewed as a mafia more than now so... Goodbye everybody  ;) ..
 
Spongyoshi said:
I have nothing useful to post anyway... And everybody seems happier anyway when im not talking so..  :mute:
Go ahead! I can't even defend myself.. The judgement has been done.
I will be lynched,you will waste a vote,one of you all will be killed by the mafia and.... i will finally see what's in my bag!  :D
I can't really try to change your ideas,and if i try too much,i will be viewed as a mafia more than now so... Goodbye everybody  ;) ..
Click to expand...
Or you could use evidence to prove that the people who voted (and FoS'd) you are wrong. Plus, there isn't enough votes on you to be lynched, so judgement hasn't been done. Being quiet isn't going to help you either, seeing as that's the reason you're being voted for.

Going to edit my question to you from before, I'd like to hear about how you feel about the reasons people voted you out so far. Do you feel like you've been lurking in the shadows? Why are a lot of your posts "I dunno who I'll vote for"?
 
Well,if im only lynched because "im lurking in the shadows" well,im not the only one  :p
And if im rarely unsure... Well,im not the only one too and im trying to be honest and not making harsh desition or i have multiple choices to vote as..
But when i try to talk,im annoying mostly everybody  :mute:
Anyway,i can't really think of who the mafia is... I mostly suspect Sashe,Billy and also Nintendofan (for starting this bandwagon mostly but also other reasons)
But seriously... Do you don't have any more suspection than just "too quiet"  ???
 
Spongyoshi said:
I mostly suspect Sashe,Billy and also Nintendofan (for starting this bandwagon mostly but also other reasons)
But seriously... Do you don't have any more suspection than just "too quiet"  ???
Click to expand...

Yes - why do you always wait till other people vote? I don't see a problem to vote for someone if you have enough evidence to suspect him except if you want to vote last to be sure that a townie will be lynched. Also, why do you suspect me, NFan and Billy except for voting for you?
 
I've been suspecting Billy from the start because he is also usually passive and like to follow others.
I've been suspecting NintendoFan because... He looks really suspective from the start  :p
And i've been suspecting you because you seemed to follow others as well and being a litte quited but after some reflexion... i don't really suspect you that much compared to Billy and Nintendofan.

Vote:Billy12510

Also,if i wait for others... Because i never have "enough" evidence and usually dunno for who to vote most of time...  :-\
 
Spongyoshi said:
I've been suspecting Billy from the start because he is also usually passive and like to follow others.
I've been suspecting NintendoFan because... He looks really suspective from the start  :p
And i've been suspecting you because you seemed to follow others as well and being a litte quited but after some reflexion... i don't really suspect you that much compared to Billy and Nintendofan.

Vote:Billy12510

Also,if i wait for others... Because i never have "enough" evidence and usually dunno for who to vote most of time...  :-\
Click to expand...

How can you never have enough evidence to vote for anyone? Others have, like us who suspect you now. By the way, why do you think that Billy likes to follow others? I don't think so... :-\
 
At the start of the game,everybody was voting for a no lynch
Billy=A vote should match what there is to vote on at this point: not much. No vote
Click to expand...
After Slacker said to vote for nobody and everybody agreed
Billy=Slacker makes a good point. The only issue is... how do we prove that one is good? There's not a whole lot to go on, and just throwing out names doesn't do a whole lot. (Albeit it's better then nothing.)
withdrawing my vote Haste makes waste, and who knows who's going to survive the night? Best to try and figure things out while everyone's still alive.
Click to expand...
Well,that was my exemple... Just an opinion.  :p
 
Spongyoshi said:
At the start of the game,everybody was voting for a no lynch
Billy=A vote should match what there is to vote on at this point: not much. No vote
Click to expand...
After Slacker said to vote for nobody and everybody agreed
Billy=Slacker makes a good point. The only issue is... how do we prove that one is good? There's not a whole lot to go on, and just throwing out names doesn't do a whole lot. (Albeit it's better then nothing.)
withdrawing my vote Haste makes waste, and who knows who's going to survive the night? Best to try and figure things out while everyone's still alive.
Click to expand...
Well,that was my exemple... Just an opinion.  :p
Click to expand...

Actually not only Billy agreed with Slacker then. He withdrawed his "No Lynch" vote but he voted for that again at the end of the day. Do you have other examples?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top