Yoshi's Island Mafia Gaiden (End - Kamek Won)

[NintendoFan]

So for starters...

Unvote: Sashe
Goddamn my laziness... not much of an excuse for why this was retracted, but I only vote for Sashe to get him to respond to questioning. It worked.

He's definitely guilty of bandwagoning... but so are Gman and Spong to an extent. I'm growing a bit wary of Spong's lurking around in the shadows... he'd rather wait around then vote. Which might be explained by his lack of experience. Another explanation is he's hiding something. If Gman wasn't guilty of doing the same thing... I'd have faith in a concrete vote.

FoS: Gman & Spong

The reason Spongyoshi is lurking is because of his timezone. He lives in France, so while we're talking he's supposed to be fast asleep. Just saying.

 

[H-J Kaabii]

So for starters...

Unvote: Sashe
Goddamn my laziness... not much of an excuse for why this was retracted, but I only vote for Sashe to get him to respond to questioning. It worked.

He's definitely guilty of bandwagoning... but so are Gman and Spong to an extent. I'm growing a bit wary of Spong's lurking around in the shadows... he'd rather wait around then vote. Which might be explained by his lack of experience. Another explanation is he's hiding something. If Gman wasn't guilty of doing the same thing... I'd have faith in a concrete vote.

FoS: Gman & Spong

The reason Spongyoshi is lurking is because of his timezone. He lives in France, so while we're talking he's supposed to be fast asleep. Just saying.

No. Billy has a valid point. Spong isn't being decisive, his posts have mainly been 'I'm not sure who to vote...'

I blame myself for not analyzing Matt and Gman's posts so far. I am busy but I guess that's not a valid enough reason.

 

[NintendoFan]

So for starters...

Unvote: Sashe
Goddamn my laziness... not much of an excuse for why this was retracted, but I only vote for Sashe to get him to respond to questioning. It worked.

He's definitely guilty of bandwagoning... but so are Gman and Spong to an extent. I'm growing a bit wary of Spong's lurking around in the shadows... he'd rather wait around then vote. Which might be explained by his lack of experience. Another explanation is he's hiding something. If Gman wasn't guilty of doing the same thing... I'd have faith in a concrete vote.

FoS: Gman & Spong

The reason Spongyoshi is lurking is because of his timezone. He lives in France, so while we're talking he's supposed to be fast asleep. Just saying.

No. Billy has a valid point. Spong isn't being decisive, his posts have mainly been 'I'm not sure who to vote...'

I blame myself for not analyzing Matt and Gman's posts so far. I am busy but I guess that's not a valid enough reason.

I guess so, but this is his first Mafia game he's ever been in(As far as I know...) and he lacks some necessary experience.

 

[Gmanextreme9]

So for starters...

Unvote: Sashe
Goddamn my laziness... not much of an excuse for why this was retracted, but I only vote for Sashe to get him to respond to questioning. It worked.

He's definitely guilty of bandwagoning... but so are Gman and Spong to an extent. I'm growing a bit wary of Spong's lurking around in the shadows... he'd rather wait around then vote. Which might be explained by his lack of experience. Another explanation is he's hiding something. If Gman wasn't guilty of doing the same thing... I'd have faith in a concrete vote.

FoS: Gman & Spong

Honestly, part of the reason I haven't been posting as much is because of my lack of experience. Sorry for not clarifying this, but this is my first Mafia game. I'm still figuring out how the game works and things like that. Another thing is that nothing has gone on over the past few days and I haven't had anything to post. And on a side note, I won't be nearly as active this week because of me being extremely busy. I'll probably be posting at the same rate I have been I just won't be reading as much.

 

[Sashe2705]

He's definitely guilty of bandwagoning... but so are Gman and Spong to an extent. I'm growing a bit wary of Spong's lurking around in the shadows... he'd rather wait around then vote. Which might be explained by his lack of experience. Another explanation is he's hiding something. If Gman wasn't guilty of doing the same thing... I'd have faith in a concrete vote.

FoS: Gman & Spong

You're probably right, but NFan has been quiet, too. Well, the first killed was KB and then Aegis. They both were people who wanted NFan lynched. So the Mafia may know what is in NFan's bag. That makes me think... if Slacker's theory's right and there are 2 Mafia players with one of them being able to look at others' bags, it's possible that NFan and Spong are Mafia partners. NFan defended Spong several times when you suspected him. Plus, NFan already looked at GMan's bag, so it's possible that he can look at others' bags. I doubt that, though, because Slacker received a PM and he looked in another player's bag (except if he doesn't have some kind of a special role). By the way, Slacker, can you finally tell us which bag did you look in and what was in it. I don't see a reason why not to tell us, except if you know who has Baby Mario. I don't have much evidence, though, and Yoshiman said that whoever has the most votes is out, so we should be careful about who are we going to vote for. Billy, you're right that GMan has been bandwagoning, too, but I don't suspect him. However, the person that I suspect the most is still Richard.

FoS: NFan, Spong and Richard

 

[H-J Kaabii]

I feel like the dreams and bag openings are things that a different player each night will get to experience.

Sashe, what is your primary reason to suspect Richard?

 

[Spongyoshi]

If i don't have strong opinion,it's just because.... Well,NOTHING HAPPENS!  :what:
But if i really had to vote to someone... That would be Prince Richard 
But im gonna wait before voting too  :mute:

 

[Sashe2705]

I feel like the dreams and bag openings are things that a different player each night will get to experience.

Sashe, what is your primary reason to suspect Richard?

As I said, he defended me when you suspected me and I was the only person beside him who voted for Aegis. He may've thought that Aegis has Baby Mario because he had a Goomba in his bag. I'm still thinking that he was trying to make people vote for Aegis. And all that suicide thing seems a bit suspicious to me... .

 

[kinetic563]

*raises from dead again*

So, what? Am I gunna get lynched? Does this mean...I die? Or...will I be unconcious like my dear Aegis?

Gods...please spare me the pain. I wish to be in a comatose with my beloved.

Suspect me all you want. ALL I CARE FOR IS MY AEGIS! ARRRRRRGGGGHHHHHH!!!

 

[Billy12510]

If i don't have strong opinion,it's just because.... Well,NOTHING HAPPENS!  :what:
But if i really had to vote to someone... That would be Prince Richard 
But im gonna wait before voting too  :mute:

Well you really have to vote for someone.

If we just wait around for the perfect evidence to fall in our lap to create that strong opinion, the mafia will destroy us all.
If you want something to happen... I'll arrange it for you.
Vote: Spongyoshi

 

[Sashe2705]

I'll vote for the person who I suspect the most. Vote:Richard

 

[Slacker]

By the way, Slacker, can you finally tell us which bag did you look in and what was in it. I don't see a reason why not to tell us, except if you know who has Baby Mario.

About the dream. It was identical to NFan's. I drifted off to sleep and everyone's bags (excluding my own) were laid before me and I got to open one of them. When I did, a Goomba jumped out and a Power Star saved me. The purpose of the Goomba was to make the owner believe that they could possibly have Baby Mario; more importantly, the description of the Goomba strongly hinted that its owner was innocent although it was never confirmed.

Why so you know one more person who doesn't have the Baby Mario you're after? Giving up the name now would be useless, if that person is in jeopardy of being lynched, then I'll fess up. Until we find out more about the game mechanics, I do not feel the slightest bit comfortable possibly giving the mafia an extra advantage.

That being said, there's only one safe vote for this day phase; I hate to do this, but he's going to be inactive anyway.
Vote: Gman

I'm voting Gman because it prevents us from losing the game, and we can do more investigating during the night phase to hopefully give town an edge. This is a tactical move as there are bits and pieces of Yoshiman's story we can go after. Obviously, it's pretty likely he's innocent, but are we really going to nab a bad guy based on randomly voting like this?

 

[Timmy]

I'm still pretty suspicious of Spong as I said here & here. Also, I find that he's been doing what (almost) everyone said to Slacker's 3rd question (lemme recap).

What type of tendencies/behaviors do you think the menace would show?

Spoiler: Everyone's Answers

3. My first instinct would be to try to act out as the good guy to prevent them from being suspicious. But also being silent as to watch the rest of us bickering on & on while they LAUGH THEIR A** OFF.

I think they would prefear to hide and be agressive but secretly.

3. Hmm... it could very depending on the person. Speaking from experience a mafia members tendencies tend to lean towards blending in with a crowd and silently killing off the people in said crowd.

3. I think he would act like everyone else. It depends on how experienced said player is.

3. As per 2, try to get on everyone's good side, eliminate those who make themselves suspicious, and then go for the decisive kill. Alternatively they could play passively and seem inconspicuous.

3. Ideally, kingboo's actions of going after NFan (but looks more like a jester). Realistically, staying quiet and jumping on a bandwagon if necessary, otherwise fighting it so they can look innocent.

3. He'll act as an innocent and stay quiet until someone suspects him.

3. I'd see the menace trying to sheep or speedlynch whoever their target is.

(Voodu and KB's response to Question 3 don't exactly mention sheeping, and note Matt/Aegis/Gman never answered them.)

@Slacker: May I ask if you had checked my bag Night 1? Cause I'm wondering if your theory about the doublevoter was just a lucky guess.
(You don't need to answer this if you don't want to though lol)

For the double voter, it's possible that the two votes won't show in the vote counts. For example, it's a passive ability only activated when someone is one vote away from being lynched. It's not the biggest deal in the entire world, I'd say that the double voter is most likely a clear though since (presumably) mafia just has a killing power. I'd say it's a good thing we don't know who exactly has the ability yet and for the six of us to just be careful when voting.

 

[Timmy]

EBWOP - Forgot to actually vote.

Vote: Spong

(Unofficial) Vote Count
- Gman: 1 (Slacker)
- Richard: 1 (Sashe)
- Spong: 2 (Timmy, Billy)

(Do note that another 3 votes on Spong will hammer cause of my Baby Yoshi, but it's not like the Gamemod can officially confirm that I'm the owner and plus Billy and I were 1 of the 6 voters Day 1 for No Lynch before the hammer so there may be doubts )

 

[Gmanextreme9]

By the way, Slacker, can you finally tell us which bag did you look in and what was in it. I don't see a reason why not to tell us, except if you know who has Baby Mario.

About the dream. It was identical to NFan's. I drifted off to sleep and everyone's bags (excluding my own) were laid before me and I got to open one of them. When I did, a Goomba jumped out and a Power Star saved me. The purpose of the Goomba was to make the owner believe that they could possibly have Baby Mario; more importantly, the description of the Goomba strongly hinted that its owner was innocent although it was never confirmed.

Why so you know one more person who doesn't have the Baby Mario you're after? Giving up the name now would be useless, if that person is in jeopardy of being lynched, then I'll fess up. Until we find out more about the game mechanics, I do not feel the slightest bit comfortable possibly giving the mafia an extra advantage.

That being said, there's only one safe vote for this day phase; I hate to do this, but he's going to be inactive anyway.
Vote: Gman

I'm voting Gman because it prevents us from losing the game, and we can do more investigating during the night phase to hopefully give town an edge. This is a tactical move as there are bits and pieces of Yoshiman's story we can go after. Obviously, it's pretty likely he's innocent, but are we really going to nab a bad guy based on randomly voting like this?

I never said I was inactive, I just said I won't be online all the time. Also, instead of random voting I am going to vote for someone who I actually still have an FoS on. Vote: Richard

 

[Billy12510]

I never said I was inactive, I just said I won't be online all the time. Also, instead of random voting I am going to vote for someone who I actually still have an FoS on. Vote: Richard

I'll vote for the person who I suspect the most. Vote:Richard

Something about Unknown's behavior's been bothering me... seeing as how you two are so convinced of his guilt perhaps you can assist me. Why would a mafia person keep talking about wanting to die so much? These statements Unknown keeps making, they're attention grabbing, they throw suspicion on him. Which isn't the kind of behavior a mafia role tends to show. All it seems to show me is that he wants to be with his precious waifu Aegis. Personally I think he's innocent, and you guys are just voting him because he's not really contributing much, which is a crime a LOT of us are guilty of.

 

[NintendoFan]

it's possible that NFan and Spong are Mafia partners. NFan defended Spong several times when you suspected him. Plus, NFan already looked at GMan's bag, so it's possible that he can look at others' bags.

Actually, one of the reasons i'm defending Spong here is because he is my friend.

I really don't think Spong is Mafia, because if he was, i'd feel he'd be much more silent and looks like he's trying to hide something, because this is his first game, and wouldn't know how to act.

@Slacker I had a dream which cleared all suspicion of Gman.

 

[Snowy620]

it's possible that NFan and Spong are Mafia partners. NFan defended Spong several times when you suspected him. Plus, NFan already looked at GMan's bag, so it's possible that he can look at others' bags.

Actually, one of the reasons i'm defending Spong here is because he is my friend.

I really don't think Spong is Mafia, because if he was, i'd feel he'd be much more silent and looks like he's trying to hide something, because this is his first game, and wouldn't know how to act.

@Slacker I had a dream which cleared all suspicion of Gman.

hey dicknuts, you're out of the game. Stop playing it.

 

[H-J Kaabii]

Okay, so I'm back now, and it seems as though no final vote has been made on who should be lynched... hrmm...
Well, I guess the whole thing with NFan is sort of making it confusing I guess. I did tell VIP to boot him on Saturday but that was mostly on the part of him not showing up for a while plus multiple things from the previous dates (freaking editing posts and back-seat modding.) However, Nfan Showed up before VIP made the replacement posts so I'm going to give NFan a lucky break on this one - you have one final chance, and please tell me when you'll not be on for a while, okay?

NFan is no longer booted, return to the game at once.

...oh right - the deadline though...
Well it has officially pasted... but I did say there wasn't going to be a No Lynch...

24-Hour Deadline extension to vote someone out or something might happen.
It might be a No-Lynch, it might not. Whoever has the most votes will be out, however.
Total Votes:
No Vote: 10
Sashe: 1 (Billy12510)

...and thanks VIP for helping out while I was away.

Snowy, please.

 

[Slacker]

I'm starting to think none of you read my post. Gman wasn't a random vote. I know he's looking innocent. If we lynch someone who has Baby Mario, we lose. We know Gman has a Goomba. I'm trying to keep the endgame in perspective here guys. Just trying to think outside the box but ah well, we're way past deadline so I guess whoever votes Spong/Kinetic next locks in that vote.

In my personal opinion, I think the best chance at mafia is Billy and Prince. Maybe Sashe or HJ, but I'm still leaning towards innocent on them. Let me think on this.

Spong is acting like someone in his first mafia game. He's afraid to vote because he doesn't want people to be mad at him or vote without hard evidence, which is making him look more suspicious. I doubt he's mafia.

@Timmy - I only had the vision during the second night phase. The comment you quoted was just me talking from experience from hosting games. If you were the host, you wouldn't want anyone to know who was the double voter was and my description is one easy way to work around that.