Yoshi's Island Mafia 2 : Revenge of the Koopas (Endgame)

Why are you pointing your suspicion toward Billy just out of the blue? Where is your reasoning behind this?

The more you fail at giving the rest of us coherent answers, the more we will suspect you.

((as for school thing, why did you join if that was the case))
 
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!

And I've had suspicion of Billy since people first suspected him very early on..but me not posting I couldn't really share it!  And I've given you reasoning already? Now your just jumping on me! I think he is spending to much time jumping on other people saying they are mafia, so we take attention away from him! Who could very well be mafia
 
Detective Koshi said:
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!
I'm afraid your word choice doesn't help you. If you think my investigation is an act, you'll need to prove that. If you have any suspicions of me based on my early statement, you've misinterpreted it much like the others that have done the same thing. You're explanations are failing to avoid scrutiny, and since you want action so much, I'm punching your ticket across the Styx.
Vote: Koshi
 
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!
I'm afraid your word choice doesn't help you. If you think my investigation is an act, you'll need to prove that. If you have any suspicions of me based on my early statement, you've misinterpreted it much like the others that have done the same thing. You're explanations are failing to avoid scrutiny, and since you want action so much, I'm punching your ticket across the Styx.
Vote: Koshi
Fair enough, the reason I suspect you is you can never have one person suspecting you without going crazy. Sashe suspected you at the start you couldn't handle it and you said if anyone is suspicious it's Unknown, know that I'm here, you have jumped on me to draw the attention away from you, in my opinion. Which is why I have to Vote:Billy
 
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!
I'm afraid your word choice doesn't help you. If you think my investigation is an act, you'll need to prove that. If you have any suspicions of me based on my early statement, you've misinterpreted it much like the others that have done the same thing. You're explanations are failing to avoid scrutiny, and since you want action so much, I'm punching your ticket across the Styx.
Vote: Koshi
Fair enough, the reason I suspect you is you can never have one person suspecting you without going crazy. Sashe suspected you at the start you couldn't handle it and you said if anyone is suspicious it's Unknown, know that I'm here, you have jumped on me to draw the attention away from you, in my opinion. Which is why I have to Vote:Billy
And I said having suspicion is fine, as long as you have the evidence to back it up. As for this (being your vote), we've been down this rabbit hole before and it's gotten us no where.
 
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!
I'm afraid your word choice doesn't help you. If you think my investigation is an act, you'll need to prove that. If you have any suspicions of me based on my early statement, you've misinterpreted it much like the others that have done the same thing. You're explanations are failing to avoid scrutiny, and since you want action so much, I'm punching your ticket across the Styx.
Vote: Koshi
Fair enough, the reason I suspect you is you can never have one person suspecting you without going crazy. Sashe suspected you at the start you couldn't handle it and you said if anyone is suspicious it's Unknown, know that I'm here, you have jumped on me to draw the attention away from you, in my opinion. Which is why I have to Vote:Billy
And I said having suspicion is fine, as long as you have the evidence to back it up. As for this (being your vote), we've been down this rabbit hole before and it's gotten us no where.
it's gotten us nowhere because you were still alive at the end, for all we know if your voted out we could be one step closer to winning!
 
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!
I'm afraid your word choice doesn't help you. If you think my investigation is an act, you'll need to prove that. If you have any suspicions of me based on my early statement, you've misinterpreted it much like the others that have done the same thing. You're explanations are failing to avoid scrutiny, and since you want action so much, I'm punching your ticket across the Styx.
Vote: Koshi
Fair enough, the reason I suspect you is you can never have one person suspecting you without going crazy. Sashe suspected you at the start you couldn't handle it and you said if anyone is suspicious it's Unknown, know that I'm here, you have jumped on me to draw the attention away from you, in my opinion. Which is why I have to Vote:Billy
And I said having suspicion is fine, as long as you have the evidence to back it up. As for this (being your vote), we've been down this rabbit hole before and it's gotten us no where.
it's gotten us nowhere because you were still alive at the end, for all we know if your voted out we could be one step closer to winning!
I want to know what it is I've done to get you so pissed at me, that statement just sounds like your voting for me out of some kind of vendetta.
 
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
If I said that it would have sounded like a complete lie...saying that I was waiting for a good time to strike the mafia sounds like I'm more helpful..if I told you uh I forgot...you wouldn't have treated me like a serious game player, which I'm hoping to be! It was stupid of me, but I didn't wanna be treated as some kid who couldn't even keep up!

The sign ups were far before vacation, and I meant to reply, I just lost track of time!
I'm afraid your word choice doesn't help you. If you think my investigation is an act, you'll need to prove that. If you have any suspicions of me based on my early statement, you've misinterpreted it much like the others that have done the same thing. You're explanations are failing to avoid scrutiny, and since you want action so much, I'm punching your ticket across the Styx.
Vote: Koshi
Fair enough, the reason I suspect you is you can never have one person suspecting you without going crazy. Sashe suspected you at the start you couldn't handle it and you said if anyone is suspicious it's Unknown, know that I'm here, you have jumped on me to draw the attention away from you, in my opinion. Which is why I have to Vote:Billy
And I said having suspicion is fine, as long as you have the evidence to back it up. As for this (being your vote), we've been down this rabbit hole before and it's gotten us no where.
it's gotten us nowhere because you were still alive at the end, for all we know if your voted out we could be one step closer to winning!
Lol and you didn't consider the flip side?
One step closer for winning if you were mafia maybe... Care to clarify?
Strong FoS Koshi
 
Before I do anything, I wish to see what more TSL and Yoshidude both think of what just transpired.

Still leaning toward a vote on Koshi, though.
 
Detective Koshi said:
Of course not, it's just I have a hunch your mafia, when I voted you, you replied it would get me nowhere, but how can you say that before the voting is done?
I know why I can say that, but I can't tell you without role-claiming. Besides like I said, you weren't the first to campaign against me, and just like them you have nothing proving I am mafia.
 
Also of note (consider this ebwop) is how you claim that Billy couldn't handle it. There actually wasn't much going on between Billy and Sashe, all Billy really responded with was 'having suspicion isn't bad but you voted me please explain'.

There's a strong emotional flustered vibe coming from your posts Koshi, is it because you perhaps can't take the heat?

Looking back now I'm going to ease some of my suspicion off Sashe, I was a bit too forceful on isolated word choices...

Revised FoS to moderate on Sashe

Unknown, my view on what has transpired thus far is Koshi is digging himself into a hole by staying silent for no good reason, claiming that we are wasting time getting reads on each other, and then saying some rather self-incriminating things - particularly the one step closer to winning bit. Regardless of what he's been doing outside of the game time, I found his wanting to have a strategy to find Mafia by letting the day end quicker, yet not being able to substantiate the ideas he wants, vague and evasive.

Koshi please quote the post you are referring to so I can put it into context.
 
The Shattered Legacy said:
Also of note (consider this ebwop) is how you claim that Billy couldn't handle it. There actually wasn't much going on between Billy and Sashe, all Billy really responded with was 'having suspicion isn't bad but you voted me please explain'.

There's a strong emotional flustered vibe coming from your posts Koshi, is it because you perhaps can't take the heat?

Looking back now I'm going to ease some of my suspicion off Sashe, I was a bit too forceful on isolated word choices...

Revised FoS to moderate on Sashe

Unknown, my view on what has transpired thus far is Koshi is digging himself into a hole by staying silent for no good reason, claiming that we are wasting time getting reads on each other, and then saying some rather self-incriminating things - particularly the one step closer to winning bit. Regardless of what he's been doing outside of the game time, I found his wanting to have a strategy to find Mafia by letting the day end quicker, yet not being able to substantiate the ideas he wants, vague and evasive.

Koshi please quote the post you are referring to so I can put it into context.


(I apologize for not quoting)
the reason I am suspicious is after Sashe called him out on being suspicius, instead of having a good counter, he just jumped onto Unknown, to take the eat on himself, also the fact that he seemed so sure I would get no where with my vote. its these things making me suspicious
 
Detective Koshi said:
The Shattered Legacy said:
Also of note (consider this ebwop) is how you claim that Billy couldn't handle it. There actually wasn't much going on between Billy and Sashe, all Billy really responded with was 'having suspicion isn't bad but you voted me please explain'.

There's a strong emotional flustered vibe coming from your posts Koshi, is it because you perhaps can't take the heat?

Looking back now I'm going to ease some of my suspicion off Sashe, I was a bit too forceful on isolated word choices...

Revised FoS to moderate on Sashe

Unknown, my view on what has transpired thus far is Koshi is digging himself into a hole by staying silent for no good reason, claiming that we are wasting time getting reads on each other, and then saying some rather self-incriminating things - particularly the one step closer to winning bit. Regardless of what he's been doing outside of the game time, I found his wanting to have a strategy to find Mafia by letting the day end quicker, yet not being able to substantiate the ideas he wants, vague and evasive.

Koshi please quote the post you are referring to so I can put it into context.


(I apologize for not quoting)
the reason I am suspicious is after Sashe called him out on being suspicius, instead of having a good counter, he just jumped onto Unknown, to take the eat on himself, also the fact that he seemed so sure I would get no where with my vote. its these things making me suspicious
Well where IS your evidence I'm part of the mafia? I'm still waiting for a proper explanation.
 
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
The Shattered Legacy said:
Also of note (consider this ebwop) is how you claim that Billy couldn't handle it. There actually wasn't much going on between Billy and Sashe, all Billy really responded with was 'having suspicion isn't bad but you voted me please explain'.

There's a strong emotional flustered vibe coming from your posts Koshi, is it because you perhaps can't take the heat?

Looking back now I'm going to ease some of my suspicion off Sashe, I was a bit too forceful on isolated word choices...

Revised FoS to moderate on Sashe

Unknown, my view on what has transpired thus far is Koshi is digging himself into a hole by staying silent for no good reason, claiming that we are wasting time getting reads on each other, and then saying some rather self-incriminating things - particularly the one step closer to winning bit. Regardless of what he's been doing outside of the game time, I found his wanting to have a strategy to find Mafia by letting the day end quicker, yet not being able to substantiate the ideas he wants, vague and evasive.

Koshi please quote the post you are referring to so I can put it into context.


(I apologize for not quoting)
the reason I am suspicious is after Sashe called him out on being suspicius, instead of having a good counter, he just jumped onto Unknown, to take the eat on himself, also the fact that he seemed so sure I would get no where with my vote. its these things making me suspicious
Well where IS your evidence I'm part of the mafia? I'm still waiting for a proper explanation.
where is yours on me? these are all hunches, i never said your 100% mafia, its just a hunch, and what I just explained is why. You seem to be stressing...
 
Detective Koshi said:
Billy12510 said:
Detective Koshi said:
The Shattered Legacy said:
Also of note (consider this ebwop) is how you claim that Billy couldn't handle it. There actually wasn't much going on between Billy and Sashe, all Billy really responded with was 'having suspicion isn't bad but you voted me please explain'.

There's a strong emotional flustered vibe coming from your posts Koshi, is it because you perhaps can't take the heat?

Looking back now I'm going to ease some of my suspicion off Sashe, I was a bit too forceful on isolated word choices...

Revised FoS to moderate on Sashe

Unknown, my view on what has transpired thus far is Koshi is digging himself into a hole by staying silent for no good reason, claiming that we are wasting time getting reads on each other, and then saying some rather self-incriminating things - particularly the one step closer to winning bit. Regardless of what he's been doing outside of the game time, I found his wanting to have a strategy to find Mafia by letting the day end quicker, yet not being able to substantiate the ideas he wants, vague and evasive.

Koshi please quote the post you are referring to so I can put it into context.


(I apologize for not quoting)
the reason I am suspicious is after Sashe called him out on being suspicius, instead of having a good counter, he just jumped onto Unknown, to take the eat on himself, also the fact that he seemed so sure I would get no where with my vote. its these things making me suspicious
Well where IS your evidence I'm part of the mafia? I'm still waiting for a proper explanation.
where is yours on me? these are all hunches, i never said your 100% mafia, its just a hunch, and what I just explained is why. You seem to be stressing...
Hehehe... why would I be stressing? I told you I'm innocent, but I'd need to role-claim to prove it.
 
Hunches against hunches is so old school mafia lol

Unknown already made himself out to be a little suspicious from the beginning (though now it's mostly cleared up), it wasn't purely Billy's sole suspicion

Remember Yoshidude I think voted me for countering hard. Billy's defense during his accusation was 'evidence?' Which I don't see anything wrong about. The deflection onto. Unknown May have been simply to continue conversation on points which appeared more immediately concerning.

Hold on where did Billy say that you would get nowhere with your vote?

Billy you could always soft claim if that is any safer for you? You don't have to I'm just making suggestions
 
Back
Top