Hmm... I think I'm better off sticking to my guns and voting for Koshi. We're in a MYLO situation, so we should think about this a bit more... I certainly believe HJ, but I'm more confident in voting for Koshi then I am for Yoshidude. But I'll wait for my investigation to wrap up first...
Yoshi's Island Mafia 2 : Revenge of the Koopas (Endgame)
- Thread starter Yoshiman222
- Start date
Billy12510 said:
I feel incredibly inclined to change my vote to a strong FoS because of this. But if both Koshi and Yoshidude are mafia, would they really try to speedlynch each other?
Billy is your investigation the use of a mushroom? If you haven't used it yet, don't use it on me since my Metal Mushroom is still in effect (I used it in the night)
It's true...
I do feel more confident in Koshi than Yoshidude...
It's a really tough spot...
I've also put Koshi and TSL on the spot as partners in crime once and TSL didn't take a vote on Koshi after Billy and I suspected him. TSL also mentioned "I won't vote in case mafia vote wagon"... Or something similar. IN CASE KOSHI TURNED OUT TO BE GOOD and he didn't want to f**k it up?
GOOOOOOOOOOD***IT!
MY MIND IS INCONCLUSIVE!
I do feel more confident in Koshi than Yoshidude...
It's a really tough spot...
I've also put Koshi and TSL on the spot as partners in crime once and TSL didn't take a vote on Koshi after Billy and I suspected him. TSL also mentioned "I won't vote in case mafia vote wagon"... Or something similar. IN CASE KOSHI TURNED OUT TO BE GOOD and he didn't want to f**k it up?
GOOOOOOOOOOD***IT!
MY MIND IS INCONCLUSIVE!
Remember that as soon as I made my mega post on Sashe (which I think was overanalysing, looking back) everyone pretty much rided the wagon. The Koshi situation to me felt too messy and there was a chance mafia could have rided his wagon. However looking again at the votes, no-one else went on it (after Unknown and Billy) - particularly not Yoshidude (who was covering) who even just said 'I have some suspicion towards Koshi' and not 'Kshi is very scummy, almost about to vote him'. The unvotes were after Slacker's post which probably were a red herring...
Though I think at the core of it all, we've been overanalyzing too much. We should really rely on our gut feelings more.
...and my gut feeling is telling me that I wish I could vote two people at once...
Though I think at the core of it all, we've been overanalyzing too much. We should really rely on our gut feelings more.
...and my gut feeling is telling me that I wish I could vote two people at once...
Billy said he has a Spy Mushroom...
If there's something I could inquire about that... Did you use that at night? And on who? Are you waiting for some other being not of this world to give the details(Yoshiman)?
If you indeed are town, I don't have a clue why you wouldn't use it. Also, Spy Mushrooms are in every sense of the way...USELESS TO THE MAFIA.
If there's something I could inquire about that... Did you use that at night? And on who? Are you waiting for some other being not of this world to give the details(Yoshiman)?
If you indeed are town, I don't have a clue why you wouldn't use it. Also, Spy Mushrooms are in every sense of the way...USELESS TO THE MAFIA.
Because my dumb-ass forgot to use it... And then... well shit... I used it on HJ... well... so much for that.Unknown Entity said:
Vote: Koshi I want to believe Yoshidude's mafia. But I know that Koshi IS mafia. The fact that I'm alive is enough proof of that.
Billy12510 said:
He hasn't used it yet.
I sent the based god (Yoshiman) a PM about it after making that post.The Shattered Legacy said:
If you used it on me it'll be inconclusive as I believe my Metal Shroom is in effect still
Great.
Yoshidude: 2 votes
Koshi: 1 vote
For all we know the devious bastards could be holding a Mushroom.
You forgot to use it but used it on TSL? Hm?
You mean... You were going to use it on TSL but forgot?
The fact you're alive does not necessarily point Koshi to being mafia. Unless... Of course to draw suspicion away in avoid killing you.
Y'know, Billy. Both you and TSL are making me so damn confuzzled with who I should go for and whatever.
Let's see what Koshi and Yoshidude do if I take me vote out...
Unvote: Yoshidude
If either vote eachother, something fishy is going on.
If either was smart enough to get a Mushroom and both vote either me, Billy or TSL. That'd amount to 3 perfect votes.
And if the latter is the case I can know full well who's who... Unless some a**-f**kery comes around.
Yoshidude: 2 votes
Koshi: 1 vote
For all we know the devious bastards could be holding a Mushroom.
You forgot to use it but used it on TSL? Hm?
You mean... You were going to use it on TSL but forgot?
The fact you're alive does not necessarily point Koshi to being mafia. Unless... Of course to draw suspicion away in avoid killing you.
Y'know, Billy. Both you and TSL are making me so damn confuzzled with who I should go for and whatever.
Let's see what Koshi and Yoshidude do if I take me vote out...
Unvote: Yoshidude
If either vote eachother, something fishy is going on.
If either was smart enough to get a Mushroom and both vote either me, Billy or TSL. That'd amount to 3 perfect votes.
And if the latter is the case I can know full well who's who... Unless some a**-f**kery comes around.
Did Billy ever vote Koshi though?
Sometimes the mafia will vote each other if they can escape another day and kill town the next day phase, but let's hear them out
...I still demand to know which mushrooms they have
Sometimes the mafia will vote each other if they can escape another day and kill town the next day phase, but let's hear them out
...I still demand to know which mushrooms they have
Billy has voted Koshi twice.
1st time during that argument.
2nd time just a short while ago.
Koshi countered by voting Billy.
Also, just for reference, during the beginning of Day 2 after me and TSL voted eachother, Yoshidude said "Countering seems suspicious" and then voted TSL.
All four of you are f-ing my mind now and well. Whatever happens is all you guys.
I'll just watch.
1st time during that argument.
2nd time just a short while ago.
Koshi countered by voting Billy.
Also, just for reference, during the beginning of Day 2 after me and TSL voted eachother, Yoshidude said "Countering seems suspicious" and then voted TSL.
All four of you are f-ing my mind now and well. Whatever happens is all you guys.
I'll just watch.
I obviously din't read the posts did I.
Stupid TSL.
I need to sleep and clear my mind as well. My vote remains.
Yoshidude and Koshi - tell me your mushrooms and whether you used them or not.
Stupid TSL.
I need to sleep and clear my mind as well. My vote remains.
Yoshidude and Koshi - tell me your mushrooms and whether you used them or not.
I have the Regular Mushroom, and have not used it yet.The Shattered Legacy said:
Metal not in use.
Detective Koshi said:
Well then I think our path is clear. If you're telling the truth, then our best course of action is to get rid of Koshi. I'm certain beyond a shadow of a doubt that he's Mafia, and if we let him keep that Mushroom, the town will lose even if we lynched Yoshidude and he turns out to be Mafia.Yoshidude1 said:
Your need to get rid of me sparks the idea that since I have been the only one other than Sashe suspecting you, you need to get rid of me.Billy12510 said:
Because once you do, your in the clear. That's what I believe.
You can believe what you want. Play your game till its end if you so choose. Your logic doesn't hold sadly, due to this statement.Detective Koshi said:
Sure you could imply that I'm the godfather from this statement, but as I've said before, and as I'll continue to say until you understand, I am an innocent Shy Guy.Unknown Entity said:
Koshi and Yoshidude, I would like to hear your reads on each other, and on me. Unknown is pretty much clear unless you want to make the claim that they are actually mafia buddies.
I would also like Yoshidude to give his thoughts on the continuation of Billy vs Koshi.
If either of you had other night actions, please state what they were.
(In addition the brevity of your responses to my mushroom question makes me wonder if you're hiding something. You'd probably say there's nothing to talk about, which of course is a lie.
)
I would also like Yoshidude to give his thoughts on the continuation of Billy vs Koshi.
If either of you had other night actions, please state what they were.
(In addition the brevity of your responses to my mushroom question makes me wonder if you're hiding something. You'd probably say there's nothing to talk about, which of course is a lie.
)Billy, did you ever consider TSL is lying about being mason? Like I've stated previously.
Am I in the clear? For all anyone knows I could be working with Billy. Maybe the whole recruiting him is a bunch'a garbage?
Yoshidude and Koshi... If you don't say anything, you're not helping yourselves. Another thing, you guys are ultimately going to decide who dies.
If both Billy and TSL are "good", why the hell aren't they agreeing with eachother on voting the same person? Are they working together behind the scenes? Or is one actually a baddie bad?
Koshi has 1 vote and Yoshidude has 1 vote.
Who's it gunna be?
Koshi?
Yoshidude?
Billy?
Unknown?
The Shattered Legacy?
Am I in the clear? For all anyone knows I could be working with Billy. Maybe the whole recruiting him is a bunch'a garbage?
Yoshidude and Koshi... If you don't say anything, you're not helping yourselves. Another thing, you guys are ultimately going to decide who dies.
If both Billy and TSL are "good", why the hell aren't they agreeing with eachother on voting the same person? Are they working together behind the scenes? Or is one actually a baddie bad?
Koshi has 1 vote and Yoshidude has 1 vote.
Who's it gunna be?
Koshi?
Yoshidude?
Billy?
Unknown?
The Shattered Legacy?