Scariest nostalgic moment?

[MQJinx]

Mine would be the Giygas battle from Earthbound, he is the definition of "disturbing boss."

 

[Chubbo1793]

Since you're asking for a nostalgic moment, I'm gonna have to go with the Piano from SM64. Nothing else really comes to mind for me.

 

[eboyblue3]

The games I have don't scare me.

OHGAWDKARBEEZEPIKYARNZIZSCAREE

Nope.

 

[Mizore Ice]

When Luigi's Mansion first came out and I was rather young at the time...it kind of gave me the creeps and I refused to play it.

 

[Wafflenator]

Agreed with Giygas, he gave me chills.

Also, the piano made me jump, it was just surprising in a scary way.

 

[Yoshiman222]

Anything that killed Mario in a hit before the N64. More importantly, though :
SMB3 - That Big Bertha in the 3rd level of the Water World. I always used a cloud just to avoid the fish... then hoped I cleared the castle afterwards...
SMW - 2nd or 3rd Valley of Bowser level, with that tunnel that goes up and down and can crush you if you're not fast enough. I always went into that level with Yoshi to get the wings and avoid it. ;D

ACCURSED INSTANT-DEATH THINGS!

Why did you scare me so much when I was younger?
It doesn't even scare me now... but still... I hate those instant death... things.

 

[Snowy620]

Mine would be the Giygas battle from Earthbound, he is the definition of "disturbing boss."

Giygas wasn't really that scary, tbh.

I played Resident Evil 2 when I was younger and I used to be really scared of it.