[MPM:BR] Lakitu's Rainbow Castle (End)

Discussions need to start sparking. The mafia is slowly going to kill everybody out until only they remain. I know I am going to be killed for this but I have to vote to lynch 31GHT B1T S3RVANT. I have no real reason to back this up lets just say it is a gut feeling. He has attempting to start conversation with really interesting points, but in my mind it is just to turn attention away from him and onto the mafia. We know little at this point but I think it is the right choice to do. Systematically all the towns people will get killed by both mafia parties. We can only hope for a mistake between the two so they accidentally kill an opposing party member. All I am trying to say is please trust me.  :-\
 
"away from him and onto mafia"
-> Can I assume you meant that if I were mafia my attempt was to make it seem as if I were a townie and trying to help everyone find mafia?

I can get where you're getting at but besides yourself, me and Yoshiman no-one's really chipped in anything at this stage so cutting one of us off by vote will really only help the mafia since all they need is a lack of discussion.

To be fair knowing who is a Toadsworth will certainly encourage mafia to target them, however it also gives town a chance to listen to what they have to say whilst they are alive, not to mention knowing confirmed innocents means as a town we can make more accurate deductions based on what they had posted in the past phases and as to what suspicions they had.

I don't like how you want chance to save us Sax, but it's only warranting of a *minor* FoS on my part.

@Greg - How exactly is Sax being paranoid? He was being as clear as he could. Yes VIP was a survivor in MPMR, but how exactly does that make someone want to kill him off?

FoSes - Sax (minor)
 
@H-J the mafia could've targeted VIP, and since me and Swangler were mafia last game, they could've made it look like we wanted revenge on both VIP and Yoshiman. Though targeting someone for revenge is stupid. >.>

Best thing that could happen is that the mafia kill each other.

There is 2 Toadsworths left, so we'd have 2 confirmed innocents and thus give us more accurate deductions (like H-J said) if one does choose to speak up. No wait actually that wouldn't work, there's 2 mafia members in both members and can easily fakeclaim as the Toadsworths >__< Then again if there is 1 Toadsworth left, a mafiaso can claim they were buddies with the 2 dead Toadsworth... Ok this is frustrating to figure out :<

Not really much else to say lol
 
31GHT B1T S3RVANT said:
@Greg - How exactly is Sax being paranoid? He was being as clear as he could. Yes VIP was a survivor in MPMR, but how exactly does that make someone want to kill him off?
Click to expand...

A.  Sax said he knew it in his gut, not having any real knowledge, so probably he just assumed what you were talking about with the mafia pretending to be a townie

B.  The mafia would see VIP as a threat as well as being good at spotting clues on who is the mafia

GTG to bed now.
 
VIP usually is always honest in these games always telling the truth and usually makes it to the end, so I'm guessing the mafia wanted to due away with him quick before anything could be started.
@Greg, a gut feeling can always be a guess, I can't really quite tell all that Sax is thinking, but he may be right, but he may not be. Considering H-J is being so calm about the suspicion may be a form of him thinking that people may not agree with Sax, but, um, I kind of see where he's going but, it's still a bit early to tell what's what.
 
@Greg

A - at least Sax did indicate his motivation for voting me in some detail. If he had done "OMG 8B1T CREEPS ME OUT VOTE HIM" that would've been paranoia. Gut feelings aren't really a sign of paranoia either
B - based on metagame but I guess it's valid


@Yoshi

I don't know how that 'revenge' would work especially given how our players are for the most part different from last game.


@Chaos

I wouldn't necessarily agree that my calmness is because I think others don't agree with Sax - in fact it'd be more productive in terms of discussion for people to start having suspicions on me if they feel that it's warranted. I'm calm simply because I don't see a reason to freak out just for being voted.
 
There is a thing called timezones which may cause players (such as Toblet or Kingweevil) to post at a different time =p
Plum hasn't posted but he wasn't on during our main discussion phase
LP was however hmm

I'd like to hear more from Toblet and Plum about the day's proceedings so far, and what they think of my probing and Sax's gut feeling.
 
gogogogreg said:
Has anyone noticed that most players have stayed quiet in this, though they have been online?

I think the mafia are not talking because they don't want to give themselves away!
Click to expand...
I'm sorry for being asleep for the conversation but I don't live in America. :p

As much as I hate to say it, I think Saxprodigee is the only one who is suspicious. He could be trying to get us to vote for 8-bit because he is his biggest threat. I actually think 8-bit is genuinely trying to help us and to lynch him would just be stupid. It's also unfortunate that we didn't get more help off VIP and Yoshiman because they would have been really valuable members. :(

I'm so sorry but Lynch Saxiprodigee.
 
Toblet said:
gogogogreg said:
Has anyone noticed that most players have stayed quiet in this, though they have been online?

I think the mafia are not talking because they don't want to give themselves away!
Click to expand...
I'm sorry for being asleep for the conversation but I don't live in America. :p

As much as I hate to say it, I think Saxprodigee is the only one who is suspicious. He could be trying to get us to vote for 8-bit because he is his biggest threat. I actually think 8-bit is genuinely trying to help us and to lynch him would just be stupid. It's also unfortunate that we didn't get more help off VIP and Yoshiman because they would have been really valuable members. :(

I'm so sorry but Lynch Saxiprodigee.
Click to expand...

The sad part is, I don't know that 8-Bit is on my opposing party. I think he is trying to help us but in the end his only helping himself and whomever else is in his mafia party. and every body always spells it wrong its SAXPRODIGEE like saxophone not saxi or saxo. its okay if you get wrong because i am used to it by now
 
gogogogreg said:
Has anyone noticed that most players have stayed quiet in this, though they have been online?

I think the mafia are not talking because they don't want to give themselves away!
Click to expand...
It's always possible that some people don't want to get in the conversations and just want to hide in the back so that they seem less suspicious and can live longer, so honestly considering there's 4 mafia and 2 toadsworths, I'm pretty sure tons of toads aren't talking at the time as well.
 
Yeah, I came on this morning and it was still Night so I went to school and came back to find out people are dead?! Anyway, as a new member I don't know exactly why they killed VIP and Yoshiman. For some reason i'm looking at Sax and 31GHT here, but I have no clue what so ever and can't contribute anymore.
 
kingweevil said:
Yeah, I came on this morning and it was still Night so I went to school and came back to find out people are dead?! Anyway, as a new member I don't know exactly why they killed VIP and Yoshiman. For some reason i'm looking at Sax and 31GHT here, but I have no clue what so ever and can't contribute anymore.
Click to expand...
One of the rules say's you can't edit posts. Next time try not to edit anything, even if you know you made a mistake.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top