He can't jump other placements, that'd be unfair.kingweevil said:
I'll PM SZ and check the recent activity of the other replacements.
[MPM:BR] Hammer Bro's Battle Canyon (TWILIGHT 4)
- Thread starter Slacker
- Start date
I'll PM SZ and check the recent activity of the other replacements.
Anything yet?
Gotta be a bit patient, nobody responds right away.kingweevil said:
Nintendofan replaces Spirit! It's TWILIGHT 1, go ahead and start the discussion.
I'm a bit confused on the dueling system so I'm gonna hang tight and wait for something to happen.
Well how is this going to go, we don't have the option to not lynch, so either we have to have a heck of a first day conversation, or randomly choose who to duel.
Examplekingweevil said:
- Discussion
- Heated discussion
- Player B says something suspicious
- Player A thinks Player B is mafia
- (Player A posts
Challenge: Player B (in bold!!)- ALL players vote
- Player with majority is lynched
- Next twilight phase
Maybe a starting point would be to discuss how / when challenges should be made?
All players must vote, even if the person has reached the majority of votes? Like, with 12 alive, 7 would be needed to start a lynch, but it won't work until all 12 players vote?
@Vip - Basically, it gives everyone a chance to analyze voting patterns.Slacker said:
There may be a twist later in the game.
Mafia can't kill during night phases right? So townies won't lose somebody unless somebody chooses to duel one. I say we go to random.org, # everybody off according to the first post, and go from there. There is no logical way to kill anybody off without knowing anything.
Mafia can kill at night, it's just that there's essentially no night phases.
OK, I went to random.org, #s are 12 and 11, so in terms of order that we signed up that would be Toblet and Weevilsaxprodigee said:
Do you accept the challenge Toblet or Weevil?
So everybody just votes on the duelers and majority is killed? If mafia can't kill people on there own then thank you.
Went to random.org without looking at the role list and randomized it a couple of times and got 9.
That's NintendoFan.
I am waiting to see what numbers you guys get.
Went to random.org without looking at the role list and randomized it a couple of times and got 9.
That's NintendoFan.
I am waiting to see what numbers you guys get.
So you guys are trying to randomly kill people off. I thought the duel thing was to challenge suspicious people, not just whoever.
It is but I feel that aspect was meant to be used later in the game. Right now nobody is suspicious but we can't vote no lynch, somebody has to challenge another person.
Now to think about it, this IS a horrible idea to do thischaosshadow123 said:
Why would Sax come up with this?
This is very risky, but I say Challenge: Sax since he came up with the idea of randomly killing people off, instead of having discussion
gogogogreg said:
what else are we supposed to do. I was just trying to get this game rolling. We have nothing to talk about. Somebody had to make a suggestion and I did. It is the only logical thing to do, and I myself, am a man of logic.
gogogogreg said:
sorry for DP. You supported the random thing 20 minutes ago. Did your associates tell you crucial information? It seems like you just made a decision that would incriminate yourself. I am asking myself, why would one change his mind so fast. So I guess it is time to start voting. I vote gogogreg his hasty decision did something that I do not know the consequences of yet, but hopefully I will soon.
Honestly I am half guessing, like you said, we don't have anything to talk about, so I just saw the least suspicious thing, and you know the rest. But I am not retracting my vote, since someone has to die. And if this is required, Vote Sax.saxprodigee said:
I know Sax put himself in the firing line in the first Mafia game, and he turned out to be town. I'd say give him a chance. As for the randomness, good idea but gives the Mafia a large opportunity to vote off major threats. Wait until the discussion gets going.
As for now though, FoS on gogogogreg for jumping on Sax for no reason other than Sax starting the discussion. Because it's so early in the game, I am not casting any vote yet.
As for now though, FoS on gogogogreg for jumping on Sax for no reason other than Sax starting the discussion. Because it's so early in the game, I am not casting any vote yet.