So you're thinking about Greg/Mr. G, why so?
[MPM:BR] Blooper's Tropical Island (DAY 4)
- Thread starter Slacker
- Start date
He is not contributing as much as last game. I understand how this is still pretty much the beginning of the game but he usually talks more.
Hm...that is kind of true I suppose, Mr. Greg, do you have a rebuttal?
Well what do you want me to contribute? I have nothing to say, so I say nothing
I thought thats what you would say and Im fine with it.
First of all, thumbs up to Plum and 8-bit for having very similar avatars. 
Second, I'm suspicious of 8-bit. Why? Because when I said Sax was acting unusually, 8-bit didn't even put any FoS on him like he usually does. I think it's possible 8-bit could be protecting Sax.
Second, I'm suspicious of 8-bit. Why? Because when I said Sax was acting unusually, 8-bit didn't even put any FoS on him like he usually does. I think it's possible 8-bit could be protecting Sax.
I wonder if Nfan thinks that Toblet's reasoning on why I am suspicious is valid.
To answer your point Toblet, I don't think Sax being a little ditzy and not as sharp as per usual warrants any FOS given we're collectively blanking, but I'm watching him all the same, just with less aggression than usual
To answer your point Toblet, I don't think Sax being a little ditzy and not as sharp as per usual warrants any FOS given we're collectively blanking, but I'm watching him all the same, just with less aggression than usual
Why are you only interested in Nfan's opinion? There are others that could agree with me.31GHT B1T S3RVANT said:
Well his past comments almost give the impression that he's covering for youToblet said:
And yeah, always a possibility, I'll hear some others out
I don't agree with Toblet on this yet. I suppose you will have to convince me on why your opinion is correct.
It feels like this game is 50CC in Mario Kart. It's going so slowly! It would be nice if the quieter members could try do some grilling of their own without relying on others all the time.
:ghost: This has gone really slow, much slower than past games, for this one, it's been that since I died.
Well obviously VIP was/is still the life of the party.
:ghost:
Too bad there's nothing else I can do, you have to do this without me.
Now, get on with the mafia discussion.
Too bad there's nothing else I can do, you have to do this without me.
Now, get on with the mafia discussion.
The problem here is that there isn't anything for anyone to post on, everyone is silent because they don't have anything to say.
VIP it's not like you were the most active when alive...
@Toblet: totally, some peeps be purposely throwing banana peels on our progress
And LP, we didn't employ you just to get commentary that we could all work out
@Toblet: totally, some peeps be purposely throwing banana peels on our progress
And LP, we didn't employ you just to get commentary that we could all work out
VIP obviously is the VIP of the party.
Well, because everyone else is too lazy to do anything, I guess I'll have to take initiative and try to get the game moving. So this is what I think:
HJ - Probable mafia
Chaos - Possible mafia (Seriously, you can't go 6 games in a row without being mafia once...)
Sax - Probable mafia
Yoshiman - unknown
Yoshi - Probable town
Nfan - Probable town
Plum - Unknown
Luigi Party - Unknown
GogoGreg - Possible mafia
That's what I think. Sax and Greg are unusually quiet which leads me to believe they are hiding something. Usually they are quick to jump in to say something which leads to controversy and debates. However, they haven't done that. Last game Sax kept quiet he was mafia and I believe it was his game-plan to change strategy so people would think he's innocent. I feel as if he could've carried on this game-play. Greg is normally a talkative person when it comes to mafia because he's usually town. However this time I feel as if he could be a mafia member as he seems confused and doesn't know what to do. However I could be mistaken as he could just have nothing to say.
Yoshi is probably town because he role-claimed and I feel as if he really is a Weak Doctor. I feel as if Nfan is also town because if he ended up talking about ice-cream which shows how relaxed he is. However, even though I'm not totally convinced, I feel as if these two are the most likely town.
I feel as though Plum, Yoshiman and LP are possible town because the game is moving so slowly. The usual talkative people are keeping quiet which is why the game has come to a halt. I think one of these people could be mafia, but I'd be very surprised if two or more of these people are mafia members.
Which brings me onto 8-bit. In the first mafia game when he was contributing most, he was mafia, but wanted to give the impression that he was helping town as much as possible. I feel as if this is the same scenario, but this time he is being a bit more careful in what he says, hence why he is reluctant to say anything about people. He also put FoS on Nfan for talking about Icecream!! Although he didn't want to put any FoS on Sax for acting suspiciously. Not even slight FoS. He's probably protecting Sax, but there is a possibility I could be wrong. On top of that, VIP seems to think 8-bit played a role in his killing, which is my final reason why I think 8-bit is mafia. However, I'm not voting for him yet because he's the only one contributing anything, with the exception of me, Chaos and Nfan.
There... Now there's no reason to keep quiet. Get discussing!!!
Well, because everyone else is too lazy to do anything, I guess I'll have to take initiative and try to get the game moving. So this is what I think:
HJ - Probable mafia
Chaos - Possible mafia (Seriously, you can't go 6 games in a row without being mafia once...)
Sax - Probable mafia
Yoshiman - unknown
Yoshi - Probable town
Nfan - Probable town
Plum - Unknown
Luigi Party - Unknown
GogoGreg - Possible mafia
That's what I think. Sax and Greg are unusually quiet which leads me to believe they are hiding something. Usually they are quick to jump in to say something which leads to controversy and debates. However, they haven't done that. Last game Sax kept quiet he was mafia and I believe it was his game-plan to change strategy so people would think he's innocent. I feel as if he could've carried on this game-play. Greg is normally a talkative person when it comes to mafia because he's usually town. However this time I feel as if he could be a mafia member as he seems confused and doesn't know what to do. However I could be mistaken as he could just have nothing to say.
Yoshi is probably town because he role-claimed and I feel as if he really is a Weak Doctor. I feel as if Nfan is also town because if he ended up talking about ice-cream which shows how relaxed he is. However, even though I'm not totally convinced, I feel as if these two are the most likely town.
I feel as though Plum, Yoshiman and LP are possible town because the game is moving so slowly. The usual talkative people are keeping quiet which is why the game has come to a halt. I think one of these people could be mafia, but I'd be very surprised if two or more of these people are mafia members.
Which brings me onto 8-bit. In the first mafia game when he was contributing most, he was mafia, but wanted to give the impression that he was helping town as much as possible. I feel as if this is the same scenario, but this time he is being a bit more careful in what he says, hence why he is reluctant to say anything about people. He also put FoS on Nfan for talking about Icecream!! Although he didn't want to put any FoS on Sax for acting suspiciously. Not even slight FoS. He's probably protecting Sax, but there is a possibility I could be wrong. On top of that, VIP seems to think 8-bit played a role in his killing, which is my final reason why I think 8-bit is mafia. However, I'm not voting for him yet because he's the only one contributing anything, with the exception of me, Chaos and Nfan.
There... Now there's no reason to keep quiet. Get discussing!!!
its funny that you think that way about me and greg. I said he was suspicious and for some reason i still think so.
I didn't necessarily say you were working together, but strangely enough you just kept quiet in the same game. It's either coincidence or you're using Greg as a scapegoat because I know at least one of you must be mafia.saxprodigee said:
VIP talked way too much when dead this time imo (nothing on me in past games tho)
I'm pretty convinced Yoshi is WD
Lot of metagame observations here but they sound reasonable
Obtw what's your read on Chaos, Toblet
Could ppl be not talking bc they're hiding a role...?
Greg led quite quickly with the votes Day 1, but IDK what he meant by ' my logic' as the basis for lynching Weevil...
(nothing on me in past games tho)I'm pretty convinced Yoshi is WD
Lot of metagame observations here but they sound reasonable
Obtw what's your read on Chaos, Toblet
Could ppl be not talking bc they're hiding a role...?
Greg led quite quickly with the votes Day 1, but IDK what he meant by ' my logic' as the basis for lynching Weevil...