MattC said:
No, Mafia relies on good game balance and role playing and problem solving from the
participants. None of that has been demonstrated in this game and all you did on Day 6 was make it even more convoluted. You have too many roles,
you're not following your own rules, you keep interfering and adding stupid and unnecessary crap, you decided to add
yourself into the game
on both sides, and to top it all off you just let Robin ruin the game entirely. Great work.
Excuse me, but do you see all the comments below from the participants? There weren't as many as you think. Toad (and S.T.), Mario, Luigi, Yoshi, Bowser, Boo, King Boo, and possibly Toadette.
Look at Yoshiman's. He had 8 different roles for 13 people.
And what you call "stupid and unnecessary crap" is actually daily twists. I added these to make the game more interesting than a
typical mafia game. If everything is just doctor, nurse, townies, and mafia, it is extremely boring. Do you see the contestants complaining? No. They are enjoying this activity while it lasts. Just because it's longer and there are more twists doesn't mean it's bad. So what if we're on Day 7 by now? People are ENJOYING the game. The only people I see complaining are the people who aren't playing. I wonder why... And I'm not saying complaining, but complaining in a harsh way. If you say it nicer, I might actually change it. If you don't like the thread, just ignore it. You're not part of the game, so what's the big deal? Don't forget the majority of people here are newcomers. They aren't 100% experts and need some help... People need to have fun you know...
RobinFTW was the cop. He had the right BY ME to say whatever he wanted.
btw, did you even see your link? It is irrelevant to the rules of the game.
Matt, the clones were there for a reason. They don't affect the actual game except that they are extra people.
Vipsoccermaster said:
This. To put it simply, this whole mafia game was run extremely poorly. It's not how a Mafia game works. It was awful. Much awful than mafia games that Slacker and Yoshiman ran.
Bowser498, you have a lot to learn if you want to run a proper Mafia game. But this does not show that you are capable of hosting a proper Mafia game.
Bolded part is not true in several ways. Correct roles, people have been following rules, etc. I have played mafia before, and I know.
It is okay to give criticism, but PLEASE don't say it like you're acting mean. (both)It makes me really p***** and makes me feel like I have put all this time for nothing. I have seen flaws in other previous mafia games, but nobody decided to point them out, such as a certain # of percent of people confirming their role. This is JUST my opinion, but I believe this is the best thing to do.
I am sorry if I had to offend anybody in this post, but I am just stating my opinion in a non-hurtful way.
If I have to delete comments, I will for being rude/disrespectful
CONTESTANTS, I will allow you to choose. I am actually planning to do a BETTER version (very similar plot) of this in early-mid August after Accj's finishes. Vote either:
1. Continue the game and also make one in August
2. Quit the game now, have Accj's start immediately, and make another one in August. ONLY CONTESTANTS DECIDE.