Let's have a look at the overall situation:
We don't know how many special roles (if any) exist; there is the chance that there are Super Toads in this game
No attack last night means that either the Boo was incompetent yet again or they targetted a Super Toad
Let's see what the Boo can gain from targetting any of one of us:
Dark Boo - I don't think they'd get any significant advantage, and since time isn't on our side, Boo can't use a little test to confirm his hunches.
Billy - they'd prevent the approach to rationally make a decision on who's the culprit. Mass hysteria could result.
Daisy - no advantage whatsoever.
WAHA - they would be attempting to shift the blame to someone else since at the moment WAHA remains the most suspicious of our little group right now.
HJ - they'd silence all this mass talking which helps clarify the whole situation we're in. Of course that lets someone like Billy or Dark Boo step up to the plate.
Now as to our approaches:
If we end up lynching someone today who isn't a Boo, then tomorrow morning there is a chance that there will be either 3 or 4 remaining (depending on the competence of the Boo). In a situation of 3 it's almost Lynch or Lose (if tomorrow's No Lynch as well and the Boo targets a Super Toad who has two lives then the whole thing repeats). In a situation of 4, a wrong lynch would be extremely damaging for the Toads and probably let the Boo win - a No Lynch would just lead to a situation of 3 again.
If we don't lynch today, we have (most likely) 4 tomorrow morning and the situation ends up as mentioned above for 4.
The advantage we have in a group of 4 is that we have a clearer picture of motivations for each of us if we were a Boo. In a group of 3 time is not on our side since it's most likely going to be votes of "Oh My God You Suck" (voting someone who voted you) and also the third person to vote in a tie will determine the victim.
Now probably the most enjoyable part of this post, suspicions on each of us being a Boo (trying to be as objective as possible):
Dark Boo - it'd be very ironic. He claims he would make himself obvious if he were a Boo, but just how definite can we be about his (in)ability to pretend to be a Toad? His emotional outbursts might be a coverup for his actions. But in the general scheme of things over the week, there's been little to suggest his hunches have turned up no dice.
Billy - apart from the suspicion over the stack of papers and the map, Billy doesn't give off much suspicion from this camp. However one could say his wishes to take this slowly could be his trying to buy him more time to target another victim.
Daisy - I'm pretty sure she's a Toad. Boos don't get amnesia, dizzy spells and overall lack of awareness

But then again you never know. Still, highly doubtful.
WAHA - it's never helpful having a community member lurking in the shadows. His decisive vote against Spirit could just be his intent to cover up tracks behind him, but this slip up today shows that he hasn't completely proved innocence. Yes we might think he's not the sharpest tool, but we can't elicit his game tactics purely on his posts as a member in the forum in general.
HJ - his insight seems to help the Toads a lot. Why haven't the Boos killed him? Is it because there's a Peach who's continually protecting him? And in reference to Dark Boo's "If he were a Boo he'd have won since he's got a game plan", no-one has the ability to predict the exact course of the game, so game plans always have a possibility of failing.
Just in light of Staryu's "closest friends can be your worst enemies", at this stage this group is pretty tight knit so that risk can increase. But the most important thing to do here, fellow Toads, is go with your instincts. That's how we'll win this.
Now for my planned vote - at this stage I am juggling whether to vote No Lynch as a wait and see, vote WAHA because of his past suspicion, or do a Dark Boo and use Daisy as a sacrifice since she's the only 'truly confirmed' Toad and see what the Boo's response is. I know my indecision is unhelpful right now but I need some of the group's thoughts so I can see reason within one of these three choices.
And to all :ghost: - do you mind not haunting the day? We're anxious enough as it is.