Jinx's Comparisons #2 - Princess Peach vs Amy Rose

[MQJinx]

QuartrJinx?
Welcome to another comparison! For this round, I decide who I like better among Peach or Amy. Both are considered girlfriends of the main heroes in the series, but which is the better girl?

Let's find out.

RockMan no Constancy - Stage Start (Stage Start)

VS

Category 1: Appearance

Spoiler

Peach has an appearance of your typical princess, having a crown and a dress, nothing that special. Amy, on the other hand, has a tomboyish look with those shoes and short hair. And let's face it, tomboy looks are fabulous.

0

1

 

[MQJinx]

Category 2: Abilities

Spoiler

Amy has been shown to have numerous abilities, like wielding a giant hammer, spinning like a tornado, empowering others, and even using a tarot deck to forsee the future.

However, this point goes to Peach, as she can put foes to sleep, disable their magic, throw bombs at enemies, and heal her teammates of any damage done to them, even reviving fallen ones.

1

1

 

[MQJinx]

Category 3: Actions

Spoiler

Amy has done some notable actions: help Gamma pull his act together, help Shadow realize Maria's wish to save humanity, help stop Metal Sonic's plan for world domination, and stop Silver from killing Sonic.

But this point goes to Peach, because she helped Mario stop Smithy, gave power to the Star Beam to defeat Bowser, broke out of the Shadow Queen's control to give Mario more power, helped save all dimensions from total destruction, and even stars in her own game to save the Mario Bros.

2

1

 

[MQJinx]

Category 4: Personality

Spoiler

Peach is very classy, kind, and clever. She always puts her friends above herself, even going as far as risking her life to stop Mimi from falling to her doom. She's very motherly, although she can be naive at times.

But I'm giving this point to Amy. She's perseverant, optimistic, and very cheerful who always tries to make new friends, although aggressive and obessive at times. What pushes this further is that she was able to help Gamma find out who he is and free the animals from Eggman's control. Plus, she's a freaking tomboy!

2

2

 

[MQJinx]

Category 5: Style

Spoiler

While Amy has some aspects that add to her style like her Piko Piko Hammer, she is let down by being aggressive and bossy at times, and sometimes gets to obsessive over Sonic.

Peach, on the other hand, does many of her special moves with grace. This is shown by the constant hearts that appear in her special moves. She is even the master of the Love Stamp, showing she is the mistress of love in the Mario series.

3

2

 

[MQJinx]

Category 6: Development

Spoiler

Amy wins this one by far. She learned new things throughout her adventures, such as that even a menacing-looking robot like Gamma could become a friend, that you have to do whatever it takes to save the world, and that someone you like with different looks is still the same being. Peach doesn't seem to change much as the Mario series continues.

3

3

 

[MQJinx]

Category 7: Motivations

Spoiler

Peach is motivated by her determination to help her friends in time of need. Amy takes this up to eleven, and even tries to help others discover their true intentions, going as far as befriending characters that would otherwise be conflicting like Gamma and Shadow, and helping them achieve their goals.

3

4

 

[MQJinx]

Category 8: Game Quality

Spoiler

This came down to 2 games: Super Princess Peach and Sonic Adventure. While Super Princess Peach is rather decent, Sonic Adventure wins for having lots of things to do in it, as well as a lasting experience and even some emotional moments.

FINAL SCORE
3

5

The conclusion: Peach is a great staple to the Mario series, but Amy is one great character with lots of things going for her.

LOSE

WIN

 

[Luma Party]

I wouldn't say Amy has a tomboyish look.
She wears a dress and mostly pink stuff.