What is Your Favorite Paper Mario Game?

[SuperZambezi]

Since the old topic doesn't include Sticker Star, I thought it would be better to make a new one. I don't think it matters too much (everyone LOVES TTYOD), but it's nice to have the option.

Anyway, which one is your favorite?

 

[Vipsoccermaster]

As I said in that old topic, it's still The Thousand-Year Door. It had quite a lot of content, and most of the chapters were really fun to play. Partners were awesome, too. Especially Yoshi Kid and Vivian. They have so much power that they could be overused, but still make great partners for battling.

I still haven't started Paper Mario: Sticker Star.

 

[Yoshiman222]

I'd like to vote, but I'm stuck between choosing either the original and TTYD.

Gameplay goes to TTYD, just because of all the uniquw things they added. (Though there are a few things I like in the original more)
Enemies and Story goes to the original since many of them are so cool. (Now obviously, the setup in Ch.3 and 6 are amazing in TTYD, though most enemies overall were strange)

Lots of mixed things that make both games great. If only Nintendo could have stayed on this course... though I do admit the others aren't bad at all, though.

 

[chaosshadow123]

I'd have to go with the first one, though there were some great parts in Thousand Year Door, I had a better time playing the original. I only liked the third, and haven't bothered to beat he fourth.

 

[Chubbo1793]

I'm still sticking to TTYD. It had everything the original had, but improved upon it.

 

[mostachedpolar]

The original Paper Mario because it has way better music and I prefer the locations and partners.

 

[AtomicShyguy]

TTYD wins my vote. I love the locations, the characters, and the chapters didn't feel like a chore to play through. (except for chapter 2 )

 

[SirYoshi211]

My favorite Paper Mario is Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door. It added on to it's great predecessor. I liked the audience involved in the battles and almost every partner. Each chapter was well done and very fun. This Paper Mario also had the best plot that involved an ancient door sealed away with a rumored great treasure for over a millennium. The game had a great amount of humor in it which made the dialogue interesting. Overall, this was the perfect Paper Mario in my opinion.

 

[MQJinx]

PM:TTYD. This game had a lot into it.

 

[7MightyKarts]

I've played Sticker Star and still I like TTYD.
It's awesome to play Paper Mario in 3D but ... It's far easier to complete it and this it gets far faster boring.

 

[Super Mario Party]

TTYD of course. It is such a fun and amazing game. Haven't played enough of the original to say something about it. I did enjoy SPM & SS though.

 

[SkyCrusher]

The original Paper Mario. Always was a blast to play and I enjoyed the game. TTYD would be my second pick.

 

[Luma Party]

TTYD.
Super Paper Mario was too ridiculous and Sticker Star was just the old Bowser kidnaps Peach role.