Let's do a 'semi objective' review of the categories each team was meant to cover shall we?
Feel free to bash me lol.
N.B. this is not an official endorsement or anything.
Roster - firstly idk why this is even worth 10 points, 5 is more than enough.
Blue - no detail on unlock methods, and no witty comments on them. But diverse roster. 4/5
Pink - perhaps a little excessive on comments, however categorizing them into groups and alluding to them through story/unlocks is nifty. Cast is essentially recycled plus Junior. 4.5/5
Red - same reasoning as Blue. Baby inclusion is unique. Image is pleasing and demonstrates roster nicely. 4.5/5
Yellow - very clear unlock methods but with 8 unlocks would initially feel a bit empty. Also recycling SG and Magi for what is essentially an alternate skin is a bit of a waste. 4/5
Purple - similar reasons as Purple but trophy descriptions make it a little higher. 4.5/5
Boards - 10 points is reasonable.
Blue - a list of boards without description does not help a reviewer imagine them. Connecting them to bosses is fine. While the number of boards is reasonable, unfortunately there isn't enough information to rate this higher than a 5/10
Pink - as presented the list of boards is confusing but it does give a general idea of what to expect. Implementation of the GamePad from the outset adds uniqueness as does making the boards operate to different rules. 7/10
Red - insufficient information besides titles of boards. Number rather low. Would be helpful if a description or image of board was given. 4/10
Yellow - interesting use of Koopalings however there is some thematic discrepancy that may make players wonder if this is actually Koopaling Party. Again images would be nice. 7.5/10
Purple - highly descriptive boards and board features. Some localities seem rather ambitious (Lakitus owning metropolises, really?) but in all well set out. 8.5/10
Minigames - 5 is reasonable
Blue - a list of minigames is alright, however if examples were given it would be better. Puns are there but not with the same oomph as in the series. 3.5/5
Pink - minigame descriptions are brief. No indication of minigame numbers. GamePad exclusive minigames are interesting. Puns appear somewhat forced. 3.5/5
Red - not given. 0/5
Yellow - a huge list with lots of descriptions is overwhelming, but credit must be given for the dedication. 4/5
Purple - succinct with numbers but good descriptions. 4.5/5
Items - 5 is reasonable
Blue - good description of items and categorization. 4.5/5
Pink - not enough specifics though categorization is reasonable. 2/5
Red - while derived from MP6 for the most part, solid effort. 5/5
Yellow - insufficient item numbers. Also please name the items page 'Items'. 3/5
Purple - decent mix of items although prices seem too cheap. 4.5/5
Spaces - this deserves out of 10 since it's that important
Blue - lots of spaces but explanations and images would help. 5/10
Pink - interesting categorization of spaces based on mode. Some derivation (particularly from MPI/MPFS) although the unique modes have interesting spaces. Images would help. 6.5/10
Red - nicely done images and seasonal spaces are well designed. 8.5/10
Yellow - space designs are bland. Descriptions are thin. All spaces are derived. 5.5/10
Purple - Citrus Space appears somewhat derived in design from Fresh Space. Rainbow Space is derived from the Event Space in MP3 Duel Mode and doesn't offer something unique to gameplay. All other spaces derived. 6/10
Story - 5 is reasonable
Blue - Non-existent. 0/5
Pink - Interesting introduction of a new character and also ties in somewhat well with Mario canon otherwise. A bit thin in terms of in game story progression. 3.5/5
Red - Non-existent. 0/5
Yellow - This confirms the game is Koopaling Party with Mario characters. 2.5/5
Purple - Mario Party 8 like storylines are not that interesting. 2.5/5
Unlockables and Extras - not an existing category but deserves one. Out of 5
Blue - None given. 0/5
Pink - quite significant detail including other modes and descriptions. Not much in terms of figures though. 4/5
Red - not given. 0/5
Yellow - Not much asides from characters. 1/5
Purple - Not much other than trophies and characters. Expanding on this including if modes should be unlocked would be appreciated. 2.5/5
GamePad Ingenuity and Modes and Everything Else - new category out of 5
Blue - nothing mentioned in detail. 1.5/5
Pink - quite extensive GamePad explanations and features. Menu layout makes things easy to understand. 4/5
Red - not given. 0/5
Yellow - more description than Blue, but still not as much as it could be. 2/5
Purple - The last three modes seem more characteristic of Minigame modes. No Options or Extras? 3/5
Personal Opinion - not worth anything but a general impression
Blue - quite extensive listing in the core mechanics but the lack of context hurts it a little. Bring in the significance of having Tumble and Rosalina a bit more.
Pink - unique storyline but a bit deficient in core mechanics. Extensive unique features.
Red - although quite lacking, the quality of sections completed suggests that with more planning and time, this is promising
Yellow - Koopaling Party. Bring a bit more coherence to how all elements interact with each other, though individual sections are good.
Purple - rather solid although some weakness regarding spaces and the story is recycled.
Overall would be:
Blue - 23.5
Pink - 35
Red - 23
Yellow - 29.5
Purple - 36
Blue - no detail on unlock methods, and no witty comments on them. But diverse roster. 4/5
Pink - perhaps a little excessive on comments, however categorizing them into groups and alluding to them through story/unlocks is nifty. Cast is essentially recycled plus Junior. 4.5/5
Red - same reasoning as Blue. Baby inclusion is unique. Image is pleasing and demonstrates roster nicely. 4.5/5
Yellow - very clear unlock methods but with 8 unlocks would initially feel a bit empty. Also recycling SG and Magi for what is essentially an alternate skin is a bit of a waste. 4/5
Purple - similar reasons as Purple but trophy descriptions make it a little higher. 4.5/5
Boards - 10 points is reasonable.
Blue - a list of boards without description does not help a reviewer imagine them. Connecting them to bosses is fine. While the number of boards is reasonable, unfortunately there isn't enough information to rate this higher than a 5/10
Pink - as presented the list of boards is confusing but it does give a general idea of what to expect. Implementation of the GamePad from the outset adds uniqueness as does making the boards operate to different rules. 7/10
Red - insufficient information besides titles of boards. Number rather low. Would be helpful if a description or image of board was given. 4/10
Yellow - interesting use of Koopalings however there is some thematic discrepancy that may make players wonder if this is actually Koopaling Party. Again images would be nice. 7.5/10
Purple - highly descriptive boards and board features. Some localities seem rather ambitious (Lakitus owning metropolises, really?) but in all well set out. 8.5/10
Minigames - 5 is reasonable
Blue - a list of minigames is alright, however if examples were given it would be better. Puns are there but not with the same oomph as in the series. 3.5/5
Pink - minigame descriptions are brief. No indication of minigame numbers. GamePad exclusive minigames are interesting. Puns appear somewhat forced. 3.5/5
Red - not given. 0/5
Yellow - a huge list with lots of descriptions is overwhelming, but credit must be given for the dedication. 4/5
Purple - succinct with numbers but good descriptions. 4.5/5
Items - 5 is reasonable
Blue - good description of items and categorization. 4.5/5
Pink - not enough specifics though categorization is reasonable. 2/5
Red - while derived from MP6 for the most part, solid effort. 5/5
Yellow - insufficient item numbers. Also please name the items page 'Items'. 3/5
Purple - decent mix of items although prices seem too cheap. 4.5/5
Spaces - this deserves out of 10 since it's that important
Blue - lots of spaces but explanations and images would help. 5/10
Pink - interesting categorization of spaces based on mode. Some derivation (particularly from MPI/MPFS) although the unique modes have interesting spaces. Images would help. 6.5/10
Red - nicely done images and seasonal spaces are well designed. 8.5/10
Yellow - space designs are bland. Descriptions are thin. All spaces are derived. 5.5/10
Purple - Citrus Space appears somewhat derived in design from Fresh Space. Rainbow Space is derived from the Event Space in MP3 Duel Mode and doesn't offer something unique to gameplay. All other spaces derived. 6/10
Story - 5 is reasonable
Blue - Non-existent. 0/5
Pink - Interesting introduction of a new character and also ties in somewhat well with Mario canon otherwise. A bit thin in terms of in game story progression. 3.5/5
Red - Non-existent. 0/5
Yellow - This confirms the game is Koopaling Party with Mario characters. 2.5/5
Purple - Mario Party 8 like storylines are not that interesting. 2.5/5
Unlockables and Extras - not an existing category but deserves one. Out of 5
Blue - None given. 0/5
Pink - quite significant detail including other modes and descriptions. Not much in terms of figures though. 4/5
Red - not given. 0/5
Yellow - Not much asides from characters. 1/5
Purple - Not much other than trophies and characters. Expanding on this including if modes should be unlocked would be appreciated. 2.5/5
GamePad Ingenuity and Modes and Everything Else - new category out of 5
Blue - nothing mentioned in detail. 1.5/5
Pink - quite extensive GamePad explanations and features. Menu layout makes things easy to understand. 4/5
Red - not given. 0/5
Yellow - more description than Blue, but still not as much as it could be. 2/5
Purple - The last three modes seem more characteristic of Minigame modes. No Options or Extras? 3/5
Personal Opinion - not worth anything but a general impression
Blue - quite extensive listing in the core mechanics but the lack of context hurts it a little. Bring in the significance of having Tumble and Rosalina a bit more.
Pink - unique storyline but a bit deficient in core mechanics. Extensive unique features.
Red - although quite lacking, the quality of sections completed suggests that with more planning and time, this is promising
Yellow - Koopaling Party. Bring a bit more coherence to how all elements interact with each other, though individual sections are good.
Purple - rather solid although some weakness regarding spaces and the story is recycled.
Overall would be:
Blue - 23.5
Pink - 35
Red - 23
Yellow - 29.5
Purple - 36
Feel free to bash me lol.
N.B. this is not an official endorsement or anything.
Like in my assessment I felt all in all it was a solid effort and the core mechanics of the game were all thoroughly addressed (unlike Pink which is where we lost points). Not to mention that zeal is one manifestation of dedication and teamwork and everything. 